Around Greater Boston, cities are rethinking license plate cameras. Where Boston's rules stand after two hearings
Haverhill is dropping its Flock contract, Lowell faces an open meeting complaint over a closed-door vote, and Quincy now requires a hearing first. In Boston, Weber's ordinance tightening reporting on plate readers is in committee, and a plate reader question hangs over the homeland security grant.
Automated license plate readers, cameras that photograph passing cars and log their plates, were at the center of two Boston City Council hearings last week. In nearby cities, councils are making decisions about them.
In the region
From The Boston Report, which drew on local news reports:
- Haverhill decided to cancel its contract with Flock Safety, a major camera vendor. At a City Council subcommittee meeting Nov. 12, residents asked for a required council vote on any new police surveillance technology. The mayor said the cameras helped investigations but the company did not provide enough privacy safeguards.
- Lowell's council voted 6-5 in public on Sept. 22 to suspend its cameras, then voted 8-1 in executive session on Oct. 6 to let police resume using them, with a ban on sharing data with other agencies. An advocacy group, DeFlock Lowell, filed an Open Meeting Law complaint over the closed-door vote. No ruling has been reported.
- Quincy's council voted 8-1 on Nov. 10 to require a public hearing before any new surveillance technology contract (The Boston Report).
- New Bedford did not renew its contract, and Lynn is tightening its policies.
State Rep. Steven Owens plans to file a bill regulating the technology next session. "We can't be in a situation where everybody who uses our roads is being tracked," he said. The ACLU of Massachusetts is calling for a statewide law, and Flock's policy director said the company supports "strong legislation state by state."
What Boston already has
Boston's 2022 surveillance ordinance requires council approval for new surveillance technology and an annual report on what the city uses. Boston police dropped Flock after a trial, after city officials disclosed that drivers' data had been left unsecured because of a vendor error, The Boston Report noted.
Advertisement
What Boston's council heard last week
Tuesday, Nov. 10. A joint hearing took up the city's 2025 surveillance report, a revised police policy on social media analysis tools, and an ordinance amendment from City Councilors Benjamin Weber, Gabriela Coletta Zapata and Henry Santana (docket 1796; our story). The amendment would narrow the ordinance's emergency-use exception, require notice when a vendor changes, and strengthen reporting on plate readers. Weber called switching vendors without a new approval a "loophole." Police Commissioner Michael Cox said "there is no loophole," arguing that technology the council already approved, like plate readers, doesn't need a new vote for each vendor, The Boston Report reported.
Friday, Nov. 13. At the homeland security grant hearing, Ryan Walsh, director of the Boston Regional Intelligence Center, said "the city has not participated in the regional license plate reader program under this grant" (watch at 0:52:38). Weber said pages 36 and 37 of the application read as if Boston does; Walsh said, "it's not worded as clearly as it maybe should be" (watch at 1:53:30). He said the police commissioner would decide whether Boston joins (watch at 3:02:34) and that the department's current camera pilot bars direct sharing of the data (watch at 3:03:37). Our hearing story has more.
What our records show
| Docket | What it is | Where it stands | |---|---|---| | 1796 | Weber, Coletta Zapata and Santana's ordinance amendment | Government Operations Committee since Sept. 23; heard Nov. 10 | | 0409 | City Councilor Julia Mejia's hearing order on the intelligence center, the gang database and plate readers | Civil Rights Committee since Feb. 25, 263 days, no hearing | | 0192 | Mejia's hearing order to audit transparency on surveillance equipment | Public Safety Committee since Jan. 28, no hearing | | 1675 | $13.5 million federal homeland security grant | Public Safety Committee; vote likely December |
An ordinance change needs a committee report and a council vote, and then the mayor's signature.
This week
The Metro Boston Homeland Security Region, the nine-community group whose grant Boston manages, has two subcommittee meetings with budget updates on the agenda: critical infrastructure on Tuesday at 10 a.m. and planning on Wednesday at 1:30 p.m., both online (notice; notice). The council meets Wednesday at noon; the grant is not expected to be on the agenda.