Homeland security grant vote likely in December, acting chair says, after four hours on ICE and voter-roll terms
Officials said Boston won't do immigration work or voter citizenship checks under the $13.5 million grant, and could lose about $404,000 for refusing. Councilors pressed on license plate readers and a Law Department letter that arrived three minutes before the hearing.
The City Council's vote on a $13.5 million federal homeland security grant probably won't come at Wednesday's meeting. City Councilor Benjamin Weber, who ran Friday's hearing as vice chair, said as he closed it: "I'm not sure if this is coming up for a vote on the 18th," adding, "my sense is it could be in December" (watch at 4:00:50).
The Public Safety and Criminal Justice Committee met for about four hours on three orders from Mayor Michelle Wu: the fiscal 2025 Urban Area Security Initiative grant, $13,471,070.40 (docket 1675), and two state earmarks for the police department's Boston Regional Intelligence Center, $850,000 (docket 0100) and $750,000 (docket 1773). The chair, City Councilor Henry Santana, was out sick; Weber read his letter into the record (watch at 0:15:42). The city's recording and captions are now posted; our meeting page will carry the video and transcript once it syncs. We previewed the hearing Friday.
The federal strings, and the city's answers
Border work. City Councilor Julia Mejia read the application's statement that at least 10% of the grant must support "border crisis response and enforcement," which can include cooperation with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (watch at 1:38:05). Ryan Walsh, director of the intelligence center, pointed to a letter from the city's Law Department and said "the border here is generally... considered to be a water border," citing work with the Coast Guard and on counterterrorism and human and weapons trafficking (watch at 1:39:06). Asked whether he could guarantee that no part of the money would support civil immigration enforcement, including through intelligence sharing, he said "Yes" (watch at 1:39:37). Near the end of the panel, a police official added that the department is "not sharing information with ICE around any civil immigration matters" (watch at 3:01:34).
Voter rolls. Council President Liz Breadon read a condition requiring grant recipients to check the citizenship of everyone in the state voter registration database through a federal system called SAVE within 120 days (watch at 1:21:49). Brooke Amendola, executive director of the Office of Emergency Management, said the city does not use SAVE and the most it could lose is 3% of the grant, about $404,000 (watch at 2:09:41). Pressed by Mejia for a commitment, Amendola said "we have not and do not have plans to comply" (watch at 3:01:04).
Advertisement
The legal opinion. Weber said councilors received the Law Department's guidance "three minutes before this hearing" (watch at 0:25:17). Amendola said the department is "comfortable proceeding" (watch at 1:10:34). We did not find the letter posted publicly.
License plate readers
Walsh said "the city has not participated in the regional license plate reader program under this grant" (watch at 0:52:38). Weber said pages 36 and 37 of the application read as if Boston does; Walsh replied, "it's not worded as clearly as it maybe should be" (watch at 1:53:30). He said the police commissioner would decide whether Boston joins (watch at 3:02:34) and that the department's current camera pilot bars direct sharing of the data (watch at 3:03:37). Weber also asked about $1.35 million to send dispatch and police records data from all nine communities in the region to the intelligence center (watch at 1:57:04); Walsh said each community keeps ownership of its data under written agreements (watch at 1:58:05).
Another region member moved this week: Quincy's council voted 8-1 on Nov. 10 to require a public hearing before any new surveillance technology contract, The Boston Report reported.
The timing fight
Amendola said the money must be spent by December 2027, a shorter window than the usual three years (watch at 2:17:48), and that delaying the vote to January or February, as Mejia suggested, would be "a disservice" to the agencies (watch at 2:18:50). She said the council must take or reject the grant as a whole: "It has to be all or nothing" (watch at 2:50:56). Mejia said the administration held private briefings that advocates could not attend and that she still had 13 pages of questions (watch at 2:54:58).
Advertisement
City Councilor Ed Flynn urged a vote: "We can't allow the political posturing of a few city councilors to put public safety of our residents at risk" (watch at 0:21:16). He said he would look into whether another community could act as the grant's fiscal agent instead of Boston (watch at 1:05:28). City Councilors Erin Murphy and John FitzGerald said they support the grants (watch at 0:17:43; watch at 0:23:17).
A second panel from the Muslim Justice League and Citizens for Juvenile Justice urged the council to reject the money. We don't name members of the public who testified.
What comes next
- Santana decides when to report the orders out. The council meets Nov. 18, Dec. 2 and Dec. 9.
- The region's committees meet next week: the Metro Boston Homeland Security Region's critical infrastructure subcommittee on Nov. 17 and its planning subcommittee on Nov. 18, both with fiscal 2025 budget updates on the agenda (notice; notice).
- The fiscal 2026 grant has been applied for but not awarded, Amendola said (watch at 2:56:29).
The last time this grant came up, in December 2023, it failed 6-6 before passing 11-0 with two councilors voting present in January 2024, Boston Policy Notes reported. Our stories on the money and the gang database cover the rest of the hearing.