At the surveillance hearing, police said Weber's 30-day notice rule should be 180 days and called vendor reporting duplicative
The five-hour hearing on Boston's police surveillance law covered license plate cameras, the LifeRaft social media tool and a federal grant's immigration conditions. Nothing was voted on; the amendment stays in committee.
Boston police leaders told city councilors Tuesday that tighter rules in City Councilor Benjamin Weber's amendment to the city's surveillance law would add paperwork for a department that is "at capacity," while councilors pressed them on why the department kept using social media monitoring tools after the council voted not to approve them.
The joint hearing of the Public Safety and Criminal Justice and Government Operations committees, chaired by City Councilors Henry Santana and Gabriela Coletta Zapata, ran about five hours, from 10:09 a.m. until after 3 p.m. (watch from the start). It covered the city's 2025 surveillance report (docket 1708), the police department's revised policy on social media analysis tools (docket 1709) and Weber's amendment (docket 1796). Quotes below are from the city's caption record of the hearing.
Notice deadlines and vendor switches
Weber's amendment would require notice to the council within 30 days after police start using a technology under the ordinance's emergency exception. Weber said he understood the department wanted 180 days instead, and asked why (watch at 2:38:06). The department's answer was that it wanted to avoid promising more than it could deliver: "Our department is at capacity in so many different ways."
Coletta Zapata asked how often the department changes surveillance vendors and why telling the council would be burdensome when a procurement review already happens (watch at 1:41:32). The department's answer was that switching vendors for the same service can save taxpayer money, and that a new reporting duty "seems duplicate." It added: "I'm not saying that we couldn't do it."
Advertisement
Weber said the department's switch from Flock Safety to Motorola and Axon license plate cameras "may have followed the letter of the ordinance, but I don't think it followed the spirit" (watch at 22:39). Police Commissioner Michael Cox said license plate readers had been approved and in use for about 20 years, and that buying the same technology from another vendor is allowed. "I don't believe that that is a loophole," he said (watch at 1:08:03). Asked how the city learned Flock was sharing data, an official said the department noticed "anomalies" while reviewing the system in the pilot's first days and raised them with the company (watch at 2:44:44).
Social media tools and LifeRaft
The council voted last year not to approve the department's social media tools, and the department kept using them. A police intelligence official said the city's lawyers advised that continued use was legitimate under the emergency exception given "the overall threat environment," and said the department viewed last year's vote as a referral to the city's surveillance advisory board, "not a disapproval of the technology" (watch at 1:10:36).
City Councilor Miniard Culpepper asked what emergency justified starting LifeRaft, an AI-assisted social media tool, without council approval. Cox said the department was worried about "mass attacks at our large events in the city this summer," naming the Fourth of July and the Caribbean festival (watch at 2:26:48). Officials said analysts "generally" don't use the tool's sentiment-analysis features (watch at 1:30:17) and that the department has done one formal audit of its LifeRaft use, which it is still reviewing (watch at 2:40:08).
In his opening, Cox said many concerns about police technology "are driven by misunderstanding, hypotheticals and fear," and warned against "additional bureaucracy" (watch at 35:54). City Councilor Erin Murphy said she supports giving police effective tools and wanted to hear what specific gaps the amendment addresses (watch at 16:05). City Councilor Julia Mejia asked for a full technology inventory and data-sharing agreements within 14 days (watch at 19:37). Council President Liz Breadon raised police drone use, citing a drone that crashed into a car on a residential street in Brighton (watch at 25:41).
Advertisement
An invited panel from the ACLU of Massachusetts, Digital Fourth, the Electronic Privacy Information Center, a Boston University law clinic and the Muslim Justice League testified after the officials. Digital Fourth urged the council to reject the social media policy (watch at 3:34:09).
What's next
Santana said he would send follow-up questions to the department through the committee (watch at 3:32:38). The amendment, which every councilor except Mejia sponsors, stays in Government Operations until the chairs report it out; it would then need a council vote and the mayor's signature. Several officials will be back Friday, Nov. 13, for a hearing on a $13.5 million federal security grant (our preview). Our preview of Tuesday's hearing explains what the amendment would change.