On My Block · Boston Politics

PoliceCivil rights

Boston's gang database, now AVIS: no notice to people on it, three inquiries last year, two audits this year

At Friday's homeland security grant hearing, the intelligence center's director said under a quarter of 1% of residents are in the database, about 96% have been booked, and none of the three people who asked last year were on it.

The Boston Police Department's gang database doesn't get its own line in the $13.5 million homeland security grant. But it took up a large share of Friday's four-hour hearing on that grant, because it is run by the same intelligence center the grant helps pay for, and because of how it has been used in immigration court. The database is now called AVIS, the name the department gave it under a revised rule.

Ryan Walsh, director of the Boston Regional Intelligence Center, answered most of the questions. Here is what he told councilors.

Who is on it, and how they get there

  • Size. Less than a quarter of 1% of Boston's population is in the database, Walsh said (watch at 1:44:43).
  • The test. The point system still exists. Before anyone is added there is a point review, a judgment that there is reasonable suspicion of group-related criminal activity, and a supervisor's sign-off; the steps are "additive," not alternatives (watch at 1:13:09; watch at 2:04:39). Walsh said some people who meet the point threshold are not added (watch at 2:04:39).
  • The rule. Rule 335 was amended in April 2025, City Councilor Miniard Culpepper noted, and it now includes a formal definition of reasonable suspicion (watch at 2:21:52; watch at 2:23:55).
  • How long. Entries are reviewed after five years; the department removed a separate five-year "inactive" period. Juveniles are reviewed every year (watch at 1:11:38).

What people on it can find out

There is no notification. "There's no notification process," Walsh told City Councilor Gabriela Coletta Zapata (watch at 1:29:25). A person can write to the department's privacy officer under its redress process to ask whether it holds data on them. The department received three such requests in 2025 (watch at 1:13:39). None of the three people was in the database, Walsh told City Councilor Ruthzee Louijeune (watch at 2:07:09).

Race and demographics

The system stores only a name and date of birth, Walsh said, and no other demographic data (watch at 1:42:10). The department has described the database as predominantly people of color by matching entries to booking records, and about 96% of the people in it have been booked, he said (watch at 2:02:39). Louijeune asked for a regular public report on demographics, data sharing, complaints and corrective action (watch at 2:00:36). Walsh said the annual report's contents are set by the rule and posted each January, and that expanding it "may be possible" after talking to the commissioner (watch at 2:48:24).

Audits and outside review

Asked by City Councilor Julia Mejia whether the city has ever had an independent evaluation of the database's effect on Black and Latino residents, Walsh said, "I'm not aware of it." He said the department's audit and review unit has audited the system twice this year; one audit is public and the other is under review (watch at 2:53:27; watch at 2:53:58).

Immigration and police stops

City Councilor Benjamin Weber, who chaired the hearing, raised the case of a man whose listing as a gang member by Boston police was used against him in immigration proceedings, which went to the federal First Circuit (watch at 2:41:47). Walsh said he was not prepared to discuss a specific case (watch at 2:42:48). He said that if federal authorities asked whether someone is in the database for a civil immigration matter, "we would say no" and would not confirm either way (watch at 2:43:19), and that the Homeland Security intelligence officer assigned to the center has no direct access to the system (watch at 2:43:49).

Asked whether a listing could justify a search, Walsh said it "could be included in the totality of the circumstances," but officers are trained that more information is needed (watch at 2:31:32). He said the database will continue whether or not the council accepts the grant (watch at 1:52:00).

Where the council's own oversight stands

  • Mejia's order for a hearing on the intelligence center, license plate readers and federal task forces (docket 0409) has been in Culpepper's Civil Rights Committee since a June 4 hearing.
  • Weber's amendment to the surveillance oversight ordinance (docket 1796) is in the Government Operations Committee. He said Friday's hearing and Tuesday's surveillance hearing would inform it (watch at 4:00:50).

Citizens for Juvenile Justice, on the hearing's second panel, cited the First Circuit's 2022 criticism of the database's point system and urged the council to reject the grant (watch at 3:15:20). The grant vote and its timing are in our main story.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime