On My Block · Boston Politics

ZoningCity Council

Six amendments, six defeats: how each councilor voted on the parking minimum carve-outs

Proposals to keep current parking rules in Dorchester, Roxbury, Mattapan and District 2 all failed, three of them 7-6. The same six councilors backed the closest ones; two of them, Culpepper and Mejia, ended up voting for the petition.

Before the City Council sent its parking minimum repeal to the Zoning Commission on Wednesday, councilors spent most of the afternoon on amendments to keep the current rules in their own neighborhoods. All six failed, and so did a motion to delay. The final vote and what the petition does are in our main story.

The tallies below are from the city's video of the Nov. 18 meeting; the city's legislative record had not posted them as of Thursday morning. The amendments as filed are posted with the docket.

The roll calls

1. FitzGerald and Murphy: keep current rules in District 3's Dorchester (text). Failed 5-8 (watch at 2:14:54).

  • Yes: FitzGerald, Flynn, Mejia, Murphy, Worrell.
  • No: Breadon, Coletta Zapata, Culpepper, Durkan, Louijeune, Pepén, Santana, Weber.

2. Flynn: let large-project review set parking for Article 80 projects (text). Failed 4-8, with Mejia voting present (watch at 2:24:49).

  • Yes: FitzGerald, Flynn, Murphy, Worrell.

3. Flynn: strike the sections covering neighborhoods in District 2 (text). Failed 6-7 (watch at 2:42:10).

  • Yes: Culpepper, FitzGerald, Flynn, Mejia, Murphy, Worrell.
  • No: Breadon, Coletta Zapata, Durkan, Louijeune, Pepén, Santana, Weber.

4. Murphy: require a parcel-level map for every geographic exception (text). Failed 4-9 (watch at 2:49:09).

  • Yes: FitzGerald, Flynn, Murphy, Worrell. Mejia voted no on this one.

5. Worrell: keep the current Greater Mattapan (Article 60) and Dorchester (Article 65) rules (text). Failed 6-7 (watch at 3:09:29).

  • Yes: Culpepper, FitzGerald, Flynn, Mejia, Murphy, Worrell.

6. Culpepper: keep the current Roxbury (Article 50) rules (text). Failed 6-7 (watch at 3:26:15).

  • Yes: Culpepper, FitzGerald, Flynn, Mejia, Murphy, Worrell.

Mejia's motion to postpone the vote to Dec. 2. Failed 6-7 (watch at 3:31:53). The clerk first recorded Culpepper as no, then announced he was voting yes, making the yes side the same six councilors.

On amendments 3, 5 and 6, the seven no votes were the same: Breadon, Coletta Zapata, Durkan, Louijeune, Pepén, Santana and Weber. Those seven, plus Culpepper, voted yes on the petition itself.

What the sponsors of the amendments said

  • FitzGerald said Dorchester should be exempt "until it too has had its fair shake at a study," like the three neighborhoods that got a delayed start (watch at 1:39:00).
  • Murphy said she lives in Mattapan but outside the area covered by the city's Mattapan plan, and that residents should be able to "look up their address" to see whether an exception applies (watch at 2:46:35).
  • Flynn said the chair had refused any exemptions at Monday's working session and the East Boston and Charlestown delay appeared afterward: "If it's okay to add something... for East Boston and Charlestown... why isn't it okay for other neighborhoods too" (watch at 2:41:10).
  • Worrell said affordable housing developers lose an advantage if market-rate projects also get a parking waiver, and that "we've had no studies on the impact" (watch at 2:56:15).
  • Culpepper said residents of his district "need their cars" because rail transit is lacking, and pointed to a Roxbury neighborhood negotiation over a 400-unit proposal (watch at 3:21:09).

The chair's answer

Durkan urged a no vote on every amendment. She said zoning districts do not follow council district lines, that the Dorchester amendment would need a new zoning overlay it does not create, and that she considered the amendments "poison pills" because the Zoning Commission needs a legally sound document (watch at 2:08:53). On Flynn's Article 80 amendment, she said the code already covers it in a footnote (watch at 2:23:12). She said the three neighborhoods got a delay because their recent rezonings had already cut parking requirements for smaller buildings (watch at 2:39:09).

The council also voted twice to end debate on an amendment, first 13-0 on FitzGerald's and later 7-6 on Worrell's.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime