Council votes 9-4 to end residential parking minimums, with a 2029 start in East Boston, Charlestown and Mattapan
After more than two hours of debate, Durkan's zoning petition passed 8-4 with Mejia voting present; she switched to yes before the meeting ended. The Zoning Commission still has to act, and the mayor's office says it will "evaluate the implications."
The Boston City Council voted Wednesday to ask the Zoning Commission to drop the minimum number of off-street parking spaces the zoning code requires for new housing. The petition from City Councilor Sharon Durkan (docket 0809) passed on an 8-4 roll call with one councilor voting present, and became 9-4 about two hours later when City Councilor Julia Mejia changed her vote to yes.
This account is from the city's video of the meeting. As of Thursday morning, the city's legislative record did not yet show the votes.
How each councilor voted
The final roll call came about three and a half hours into the meeting (watch at 3:32:56):
- Yes (8): Council President Liz Breadon, Gabriela Coletta Zapata, Miniard Culpepper, Durkan, Ruthzee Louijeune, Enrique Pepén, Henry Santana and Benjamin Weber.
- No (4): John FitzGerald, Ed Flynn, Erin Murphy and Brian Worrell.
- Present (1): Mejia.
Near the end of the meeting, Mejia moved to reconsider. The council agreed by voice vote, and she said she wanted to "reconsider my vote as a yes instead of present" (watch at 5:35:43). That made the tally 9-4.
Advertisement
Before the final vote, councilors rejected six amendments and a motion by Mejia to put off the vote until Dec. 2, each by margins of one to five votes. A separate story lists every roll call.
What changed since Monday
Durkan told colleagues she had made two changes since filing (watch at 1:17:24). She removed language for Chinatown, where a June rezoning already eliminated parking minimums. And she added what she later called "delayed carve outs" for East Boston, Charlestown and Mattapan, which went through neighborhood rezonings in the last three years.
Reading the East Boston provision aloud, Durkan said the current minimums for buildings of four or more units stay in place until Jan. 1, 2029. After that date they become "none" unless the Zoning Commission first votes to keep them after evaluating the effects of the recent rezoning (watch at 2:37:35). She said Mattapan and Charlestown get the same treatment. Coletta Zapata said East Boston's rezoning had already dropped minimums for buildings of one to three units, and Charlestown's for one to six (watch at 1:45:05).
Coletta Zapata, whose district includes East Boston and Charlestown, had pushed for the change. "This isn't about carving out neighborhoods because they oppose change," she said. "It's about recognizing the neighborhoods that have already undertaken that change" (watch at 1:45:36).
Advertisement
The arguments
Durkan opened by citing the city's housing costs and said each parking space can add $50,000 to more than $150,000 to construction costs (watch at 1:14:21). "This is not a silver bullet, but it's a common sense reform within our control," she said (watch at 1:18:25). She said the change does not ban parking and leaves commercial requirements, such as those for hotels, untouched (watch at 3:01:17).
Santana, a lead sponsor, said the city's largest projects already set parking through Article 80 review, and that "it's our smaller neighborhood projects that are being held to outdated, unfair requirements" (watch at 1:25:35).
Murphy said she opposed "this blanket approach" and added, "Boston will never be a city without cars" (watch at 1:22:00). FitzGerald, who said he spent 17 years in the city's planning agency, called parking "a very fragile ecosystem" in residential neighborhoods (watch at 1:37:27). Worrell said District 4 had already approved projects with little or no parking under neighborhood plans and that "every neighborhood is not created equal" (watch at 2:53:42).
Flynn asked for a 30-minute recess, saying he received the committee report at 12:22 p.m. and had not read it. The chair said she was open to a recess "but not 30 minutes" and moved on (watch at 1:27:37). Durkan said the report was two pages long and the only changes came out of Monday's working session.
Advertisement
What happens next
The council's vote is a petition. The Zoning Commission has the final say on the zoning code, as Durkan said on the floor. Councilors disagreed about what the commission can change. Durkan said the commission "does not have the ability to edit our petition" (watch at 2:08:53). Later, a council member said they had spoken with "the ZBA" and that "they are allowed to amend anything that we send" (watch at 3:08:59). Banker & Tradesman noted that the mayor has significant influence over the commission.
Mayor Michelle Wu has not taken a public position. After the vote her office told the Boston Globe and Banker & Tradesman: "We will evaluate the implications of eliminating parking minimums citywide." No Zoning Commission date for the petition had been announced as of Thursday.
Our Wednesday preview has the background, including the June hearing.