Murphy seeks hearings on BPS athletics failures and a 4.2% enrollment drop; Mejia files an Egleston resolution
Three school items reach the council Wednesday, two weeks before the School Committee's Dec. 2 vote on closing Greater Egleston High, Charlestown High and the East Boston Early Education Center.
Boston Public Schools will be the subject of three new items at the City Council's Wednesday, Nov. 18 meeting. Two are hearing orders from City Councilor Erin Murphy. The third is a resolution from City Councilor Julia Mejia on the proposed closure of Greater Egleston High School.
The same evening, the Boston School Committee meets at 5:30 p.m. at the Bolling Building. Its posted agenda had no items listed as of Tuesday morning.
Athletics: "repeated administrative failures"
Murphy's first order asks for a hearing on "repeated administrative failures in the BPS Athletics Department, lost postseason opportunities, and district accountability" (docket 2154; order).
It recounts two cases:
Advertisement
- 2022: Fenway High School's boys' and girls' basketball teams forfeited their seasons after BPS did not file paperwork for a cooperative arrangement with Dearborn STEM Academy. The order says BPS acknowledged responsibility then and said staff would be held accountable.
- 2026: The English High and New Mission cooperative football team won the Boston City League but was left out of the state tournament after BPS did not submit its game against the O'Bryant by the scheduling deadline, leaving the team short of qualifying games.
The council adopted an emergency resolution on Nov. 4 asking for a chance for the team to play, and a judge denied BPS's request for relief on Nov. 6, as we reported. Murphy's order says seeking an exception from the state athletic association "does not replace the district's responsibility to meet established requirements." It invites district athletics leaders and the affected school communities to testify.
Enrollment and the future of schools
Murphy's second order asks for a hearing on declining enrollment, school funding and the future of BPS schools (docket 2156; order). Citing the Dorchester Reporter, it says BPS enrolled 44,846 students this year, down 1,978, or 4.2%, from last year. It notes the fiscal 2027 budget gives BPS about $1.73 billion.
The order asks BPS for "an evidence-based accounting" of why families are leaving, and says explanations involving birth rates or immigration "must be supported by data." It also says projected savings from closures "warrant independent scrutiny." Murphy's earlier hearing order on closures and the long-term facilities plan, filed in January, is still in committee (docket 0113).
Mejia's Egleston resolution
BPS has proposed closing Greater Egleston High School in Roxbury, its smallest stand-alone alternative school with 76 students, along with Charlestown High and the East Boston Early Education Center, we reported. Most changes would take effect June 30, 2028, if approved. BPS has said current Egleston students would get help to graduate within 18 months.
Advertisement
Mejia's resolution calls for "transparent, accountable, and student-centered decision-making" in all closures, mergers and reconfigurations (docket 2171; resolution). It says Egleston's students include many who are overage or under-credited, or who have faced trauma or housing instability. Among its asks:
- Expand BPS's closure criteria beyond enrollment, building condition and cost, to include each change's effect on students' social and emotional well-being.
- Give students a real say before decisions, and publicly report which recommendations BPS adopts and why.
- Require public transition plans that protect special education, multilingual instruction, counseling and other services.
- Explain why closure was chosen over investing in the school.
The resolution is addressed to the mayor, the superintendent and the School Committee.
What's next
- Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2 p.m.: the Education Committee holds a hearing on moving to an elected School Committee (docket 2044).
- Wednesday, Nov. 18: the council meets at noon; the School Committee meets at 5:30 p.m.
- Wednesday, Dec. 2: the School Committee is expected to vote on the closures.