The council told the MIAA it got English High's playoff ruling wrong, 11-0. Two days later, a judge turned BPS down
A game left out of a state scheduling system cost the English High-New Mission football team its tournament spot. What councilors said, what the court did, and what BPS says it will change.
The English High-New Mission football team will not play in the state tournament. A judge on Friday, Nov. 6, denied Boston Public Schools' request to put the team back in, a BPS spokesperson said, according to CBS Boston. The MIAA, which runs high school sports in Massachusetts, said the tournament, which began Thursday, would go on as scheduled.
Two days earlier, the City Council had adopted an emergency resolution condemning the MIAA's decision, 11-0.
What happened
The MIAA requires at least seven regular-season games to qualify. The team's Oct. 30 game against O'Bryant had been on the schedule for months, but BPS did not enter it into the MIAA's scheduling system before the Sept. 18 deadline, according to court documents described by CBS Boston. The MIAA counted it as a scrimmage, which left the team one game short. BPS asked the court for a temporary restraining order, arguing the game should have been counted as a forfeit loss, which would have kept the team eligible.
BPS said it was disappointed, that eligibility should depend on a team's record and not on clerical errors, and that it is reviewing how it checks schedules so the mistake doesn't happen again, CBS reported. The district said it would work to recognize the team's season.
Advertisement
What councilors said
City Councilor Benjamin Weber, whose district includes English High, filed the resolution (docket 2130) at the Nov. 4 meeting. He explained that the MIAA had other options, including letting BPS fix the entry or counting the game as a forfeit, and chose the one that kept the team out (watch at 3:11:11). He said the team had gone winless in 2023, started this year 1-2 and won its last four games (3:12:11).
City Councilor Enrique Pepén said New Mission, which plays with English in a combined program, is in Hyde Park and "the pride and glory of Hyde Park right now" (3:14:14). City Councilor Erin Murphy apologized to students and coaches for the adults' error and noted that the council had held hearings on paperwork mistakes like this before (3:16:17).
City Councilor Miniard Culpepper, an English High graduate, said the team had fought its way to a league championship (3:18:52):
We should not ask children to pay the price of what adults did.
The vote
The resolution was adopted 11-0, with City Councilors Julia Mejia and Henry Santana not present. It lists 11 sponsors. A council resolution states a position; it has no force over the MIAA, a private association that state law lets run school sports.
Advertisement
What our records add
The council has looked at BPS athletics paperwork before. On March 24, the Education Committee held a hearing on City Councilor Gabriela Coletta Zapata's order on student-athlete transfer and eligibility policies (docket 0166). There, a BPS athletics official walked councilors through the MIAA's mandatory transfer form and said the association's eligibility rules "are not discretionary" (watch at 39:31). That order is still in committee. No hearing order on this season's scheduling error had been filed as of Tuesday, according to the council's records.
What's next
BPS has not said whether it will appeal further. Any change to the MIAA's rule on game entry would go through the association's own process. The council's next regular meeting is Nov. 18.