On My Block · Boston Politics

TransportationCity Council

Culpepper asks the council to take its summons of MBTA chief Phillip Eng to court

An order on Wednesday's agenda would have the council ask a judge to compel Eng's testimony on Blue Hill Avenue. A Nov. 10 letter from Culpepper and Worrell, also on the agenda, asks Gov. Maura Healey to pause the center bus lane design.

The step City Councilor Miniard Culpepper said he would take is now on paper. An "Order to enforce summons" is on the agenda for the City Council's Wednesday, Nov. 18 meeting (docket 2165; order). If it passes, the council would apply to a justice of the Supreme Judicial Court or Superior Court to compel MBTA General Manager Phillip Eng to appear, testify and produce documents.

Eng, who is also Gov. Maura Healey's interim transportation secretary, did not appear at the Nov. 6 hearing of the Committee on Civil Rights, Racial Equity, and Immigrant Advancement, which Culpepper chairs. The council had voted Oct. 21 to summon him. The T said he was on a previously planned family vacation, as we reported Nov. 10.

What the order says

The one-page order cites Section 8 of Chapter 233 of state law and the council's Rule 49 as the basis for the original summons, and Section 10 of the same chapter for going to court. It states that Eng "failed to appear before the Body" on Nov. 6, and asks that a court compel "the attendance and testimony of and production of documents by" Eng, at the MassDOT and MBTA headquarters at 10 Park Plaza.

The order does not set a new hearing date or say who would represent the council in court.

The letter to the governor

A second item on Wednesday's agenda is a Nov. 10 letter from Culpepper and City Councilor Brian Worrell to Healey (docket 2149; letter). It asks her to intervene in the city and MBTA plan for center-running bus lanes on Blue Hill Avenue. The six requests:

  • Pause the center-running design until safety, accessibility, economic, environmental and civil rights concerns are independently evaluated.
  • Move ahead with roadway, pedestrian safety and streetscape work without tying it to the bus lanes.
  • Fund a "contemporary rail feasibility and alternatives study," including an Orange Line extension through Nubian Square, Grove Hall and Mattapan.
  • Have MassDOT and the MBTA produce crash data and safety analyses, including lessons from Columbus Avenue.
  • Evaluate the plan's stop consolidation, small business impacts and public health effects.
  • Meet with the two councilors and the Blue Hill Avenue Coalition in a public setting, with MBTA and MassDOT leaders present.

The letter puts the project's capital cost at about $162 million, including about $80 million in expected federal Small Starts money, and says stops would drop from about 38 to 19. Citing publicly reported MBTA data, it says major bus collisions on the Columbus Avenue center lanes rose from four in 2022 to 13 in each of 2023 and 2024. It also points to a state study now looking at extending the Orange Line from Forest Hills to Roslindale Village, and asks for "a comparable, funded process" for Blue Hill Avenue.

Those figures are the councilors'. We have not seen MBTA or city responses to them in the council record. Mayor Michelle Wu has said she does not see subpoenas as a productive way to work with partners in government, and the T has said Eng is willing to meet councilors or join a community meeting, WBUR reported.

What our records show

The Oct. 21 summons passed under a suspension of the rules (docket 1968):

  • Yes (8): Breadon, Culpepper, Flynn, Louijeune, Mejia, Murphy, Santana and Worrell.
  • No (2): Coletta Zapata and Durkan.
  • Present (3): FitzGerald, Pepén and Weber.

Before that vote, City Councilor Sharon Durkan said state law limits whom the council can summon (watch at 2:07:01), and Culpepper answered that it allows the council to summon some state bodies (2:10:03). Lawyers quoted by the Boston Globe questioned whether a city council can compel a state official at all. Our Oct. 30 story has more on those questions.

What's next

  • Wednesday, Nov. 18, noon: the council meets. Culpepper can ask to suspend the rules and pass the order the same day. Any one councilor's objection would send it to committee instead.
  • If it passes, the next step is a filing in state court. We will follow docket 2165.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime