On My Block · Boston Politics

TransportationCity Council

Phil Eng skipped the Blue Hill Avenue hearing. Culpepper says the full council would have to vote to take him to court

The Nov. 6 hearing ended about 30 minutes after it was scheduled to start, with no testimony. Going to court would need a council vote, and the next regular meeting is Nov. 18. Here is where each councilor stood on the summons.

MBTA General Manager Phillip Eng did not appear at the City Council's Blue Hill Avenue hearing on Friday, Nov. 6, even though the council had voted to summon him. City Councilor Miniard Culpepper, who chairs the Committee on Civil Rights, Racial Equity, and Immigrant Advancement, ended the hearing about 30 minutes after its scheduled start, WBUR reported. No officials testified.

Culpepper said he plans to go to court to enforce the summons. "We're preparing to get ready to go to court," he told WBUR. He also said he needs the council's approval to do it. "The council is going to have to vote to enforce a subpoena in court," he told WCVB, and added, "I don't want to take him to court."

For people who ride Route 28, drive or run a business on Blue Hill Avenue, the dispute is about a city plan for center-running bus lanes along about three miles of the avenue, with a full road and sidewalk rebuild, a protected bike lane, new lights, trees and crossings. City officials estimate rush-hour bus trips between Mattapan and Grove Hall could be 10 to 15 minutes shorter, WCVB reported. Culpepper and City Councilor Brian Worrell want an Orange Line extension down the corridor studied instead, and Culpepper calls that a civil rights issue.

What the T and the mayor said

An MBTA spokesperson said Eng, who is also Gov. Maura Healey's interim transportation secretary, could not attend "due to a previously planned vacation with his family." The T said Eng is willing to join a community meeting on the hearing's topics or meet directly with councilors, WBUR reported. We reported Thursday that the T had told the Boston Globe the same.

Culpepper said he is done with closed-door meetings. "We had planned to put Mr. Eng under oath," he told WBUR. "We need this to be in public."

Mayor Michelle Wu said "there was a scheduling conflict," WBUR reported. She repeated that she does not see subpoenas as a productive way to work with partners in government, and said the T has worked with the city, including at community meetings and briefings.

What our records show

How the council voted on the summons. The order passed Oct. 21 under a suspension of the rules, so it never went to committee (docket 1968):

  • Yes (8): Breadon, Culpepper, Flynn, Louijeune, Mejia, Murphy, Santana and Worrell.
  • No (2): Coletta Zapata and Durkan.
  • Present (3): FitzGerald, Pepén and Weber.

Eight yes votes is a majority of the 13-member council. A vote to go to court would be a separate question, and members could weigh it differently.

The floor debate foresaw this. Before the October vote, City Councilor Sharon Durkan said she did not expect Eng to appear and that state law limits whom the council can summon (watch at 2:07:01). Culpepper answered that state law allows the council to summon some state bodies (2:10:03). He also told colleagues that Eng had been invited to an Oct. 14 hearing in Dorchester and did not come (1:52:35).

Lawyers told the Globe last week that enforcing the summons would require the council's own legal counsel and a court order, and questioned whether a city council can compel a state official at all. Our Oct. 30 story has more on those questions.

The summons also asked for official crash data for Blue Hill Avenue and Columbus Avenue. We found no response in the council's record.

What's next

No order to take the matter to court had been filed as of Tuesday morning, according to the council's records. The council does not meet Nov. 11, Veterans Day. Its next regular meeting is Wednesday, Nov. 18, at noon. We will follow docket 1968 and the meetings page for any new filing.

The Friday hearing was not in the council's meeting records as of Tuesday, and we found no recording posted.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime