Healey's office sends councilors' Blue Hill Avenue letter to the MBTA; city and T defend the bus lane plan
Culpepper and Worrell asked the governor to pause center-running bus lanes and study rail. The city points to 120 public events and a net gain in parking. The council takes up Culpepper's order to take MBTA chief Phillip Eng to court Wednesday.
The governor's office is leaving it to the MBTA to answer two city councilors who asked Gov. Maura Healey to pause the Blue Hill Avenue bus lane project. The T and the city are defending the plan. That is what MassLive reported Wednesday, the same day the City Council takes up an order to go to court to make MBTA General Manager Phillip Eng testify.
City Councilors Miniard Culpepper and Brian Worrell sent their Nov. 10 letter asking Healey to pause the center-running design, release crash data and fund a study of rail, including an Orange Line extension under Blue Hill Avenue (docket 2149; letter). Our Nov. 17 story lists all six of their requests.
What the responses say
As reported by MassLive and republished by Mass Transit magazine:
- Healey's office referred questions about the letter to the MBTA.
- The MBTA: spokesperson Joe Pesaturo said community input is essential to every MBTA project and that the T has met with the city and the councilors. Eng, who is also interim state transportation secretary, has argued that the bus project is still worth doing and that an Orange Line extension would cost billions more and take years longer.
- The Wu administration said it has spent years gathering input: about 120 public events and five surveys with more than 1,300 responses. It said the design keeps two car lanes in each direction along most of the street, and that the latest plans show a net gain in parking.
Two numbers that differ
- Cost: MassLive put the project at $150 million, with the city counting on $80 million in federal money. The councilors' letter says about $162 million, including about $80 million in expected federal Small Starts funding. We have not seen a current cost estimate in the council's record.
- Stops: The letter says stops would drop from about 38 to 19. The responses as reported did not address that figure.
The letter also cites "publicly reported MBTA data" showing major bus collisions on the Columbus Avenue center lanes rose from four in 2022 to 13 in each of 2023 and 2024. Those figures are the councilors'. The councilors say the MBTA has not given them the crash data they asked for, one reason the council summoned Eng.
Advertisement
On today's agenda
The letter is filed on Wednesday's agenda as a communication, which the council usually places on file. The item to watch is Culpepper's "Order to enforce summons" (docket 2165; order). If it passes, the council would apply to a Supreme Judicial Court or Superior Court justice to compel Eng to appear, testify and produce documents. He skipped the Nov. 6 hearing.
Culpepper can ask colleagues to suspend the rules and pass it Wednesday. Any one councilor's objection sends it to committee. The original summons passed 8-2 on Oct. 21, with three councilors voting present (docket 1968). City Councilors Gabriela Coletta Zapata and Sharon Durkan voted no.
What's next
- Wednesday, Nov. 18, noon: the council meets. We will report the result once it is in the city's record.
- If the order passes, the next step is a court filing. Lawyers quoted by the Boston Globe have questioned whether a city council can compel a state official at all.