Ways and Means Committee

Thursday, October 8, 2026, 2 p.m. (Boston time), Boston City Hall, 1 City Hall Square, Boston, MA 02201

Hearing on Docket #0586

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Ways and Means Committee, chaired by Councilor Benjamin Jacob Weber, held a hearing on docket 0586, sponsored by Councilors Culpepper, Murphy and Worrell, to review discrepancies between market value and assessed value for residential properties and the city's assessment practices. Lead sponsor Councilor Culpepper cited data showing the 20 lowest-priced single-family sales assessed at roughly 95-105% of sale price and the 20 highest-priced sales at roughly 68-80%, including a Commonwealth Avenue property that sold for $21 million and was assessed at $12.5 million. Interim Commissioner of Assessing Hinlan Wong described the department's regression-based mass appraisal model, state Department of Revenue certification and vertical equity testing, said fiscal year 26 values rely on calendar year 2024 sales so some high-end examples were outside the analysis period, and agreed to provide additional assessment ratio data to Councilor Worrell. A second panel heard Chris Lehman of the Small Property Owners Association, who said under-assessment of the top 20 homes amounted to $83 million in fiscal year 2026 and that the residential exemption shifts tax burden to renters, and Associate Professor Ruchi Singh of the University of Georgia, who said Boston's assessments overall meet professional standards and suggested methods to improve accuracy at the top of the market. Three members of the public testified, and the hearing was adjourned without a vote.

Transcript

1:03 and.

1:46 I'm.

5:15 Good afternoon.

5:16 Uh, my name is ben weber.

5:18 I'm the district six.

5:19 Oh, geez.

5:23 towels.

5:23 We got, uh, to have paper

5:24 Yeah.

5:25 Okay, good.

5:26 we're on the record.

5:27 For that.

5:29 Uh, councilor.

5:31 Culpeper is trying to drown

5:31 me for.

5:32 the.

5:33 For the hearing.

5:34 Uh, hold on a second.

5:36 So we are getting more time.

5:38 Is coming out of your.

5:48 Do you want us to move over

5:48 here?

5:48 Yeah.

6:02 Uh, I just better luck next

6:02 time.

6:04 Give me more time.

6:25 Is the trash can.

6:28 There's one of you.

6:28 Yeah.

6:41 Oh, I think we're good.

6:44 Okay.

6:48 Yeah.

6:49 Okay.

6:51 Oh, yeah.

6:52 So get some.

6:59 Okay, let's just pretend that

7:00 didn't happen.

7:02 Uh, and bang the gavel again.

7:02 Um.

7:07 okay.

7:08 for the record.

7:09 Uh, my name is ben weber.

7:10 I'm the boston city

7:12 councilor for district six and

7:14 the chair of the boston uh,

7:15 city council committee on ways

7:15 and means.

7:19 today's OCTOBER 8th, uh, 2026

7:23 and the exact time is 2:07 P.M.

7:25 Uh, the this hearing is being

7:26 recorded.

7:28 It's also being live streamed

7:31 at boston.Com slash city

7:33 council tv and broadcast on

7:34 xfinity channel eight or on

7:37 channel 82 and files channel

7:37 964.

7:40 Written comments MAY be sent to

7:43 the committee email at

7:44 quinn@boston.Gov and will be

7:46 made part of the record and

7:47 available to all councilors.

7:49 Public testimony will be taken

7:50 at the end of this hearing.

7:54 Um uh individuals will be

7:55 called on the order in which

7:57 they've signed up and will have

7:57 two minutes to testify.

8:02 Uh um, if you are interested in

8:03 testifying in person, please

8:05 add your name to the sign up

8:07 sheet near the entrance to the

8:07 chamber.

8:09 If you're looking to testify

8:10 virtually, please email our

8:12 central staff liaison christian

8:15 chan at car ish.

8:19 Mccue hand at boston.Com for

8:20 the link and your name will be

8:21 added to the list.

8:24 Today's hearing is on docket

8:26 number 0586.

8:29 Order for a hearing to review

8:30 discrepancies between market

8:31 value and tax assessed value

8:33 for residential properties in

8:35 the city of boston and to

8:36 evaluate the city's tax

8:37 assessment practices.

8:40 This matter was sponsored by

8:42 councilors mary culpeper, erin

8:44 murphy and brian worrell and

8:45 was referred to the committee

8:47 on MARCH 18th, 2026.

8:51 Uh, today uh we'll have two

8:51 panels.

8:54 The first panel we're joined by

8:55 interim commissioner

8:56 of assessing is interim still

8:57 has that okay.

8:58 So the interim commissioner

9:01 of assessing helen wang uh the

9:03 second panel we will have chris

9:06 uh, lehman uh, the board member

9:08 for the small property owners

9:09 association and remotely we'll

9:12 have uh, associate professor

9:14 ruchi singh, uh, from the terry

9:16 college of business, university

9:16 of georgia.

9:18 She's an associate professor in

9:19 the real estate program.

9:22 Um, before we hear from our

9:23 panelists, I'd like to give my

9:25 colleagues I'm joined, uh,

9:27 today by the lead sponsor,

9:28 counselor culpeper.

9:31 And, uh, in order of arrival, I

9:32 believe councilor flynn and

9:34 then councilor fitzgerald.

9:37 So, uh, I'd like give room for,

9:39 um, a short opening.

9:42 Um, and know set the clock if

9:42 you want.

9:43 I we'll have three minutes each

9:45 for an opening if that works

9:45 for you.

9:49 clock and.

9:49 Okay, well, I'll start the

9:50 Keep track.

9:51 whenever you're ready.

9:51 Thank you.

9:52 Chair weber.

9:54 Holding this hearing.

9:55 I want to thank the.

9:57 Administration of the panelists

10:00 and members of the public

10:01 public for joining us today.

10:04 I thank my colleagues for.

10:05 Joining us.

10:06 Councilor flanders.

10:07 Councilor fitzgerald.

10:10 I followed this hearing order

10:10 because.

10:12 I want to better understand

10:13 where the voices property

10:17 assessment system is accurately

10:19 and equitably valuing

10:20 residential properties across

10:20 the.

10:23 Full spectrum of our housing

10:24 market.

10:26 Property taxes are based on

10:28 assessed value in the city's

10:30 annual valuation process is

10:32 intended to approximate fair

10:33 market value.

10:35 The data that prompted this

10:38 hearing raises some important

10:40 questions, especially when

10:41 you're looking at the lowest

10:43 price single family sales and

10:45 the highest price residential

10:47 sales over multiple years.

10:53 With see a fairly consistent

10:55 difference and the data set

10:58 provided to us the 20 lowest

10:59 priced single family homes sold

11:02 in 2022 were assessed at a

11:05 weighted average of about 105%

11:06 of their sale price.

11:11 With 2023 it was about 103% for

11:16 2024 approximately 95.5% on the

11:17 high end.

11:19 That's why we're here today.

11:20 The pattern looks very

11:21 different.

11:23 The 20 highest priced

11:26 residential sales were assessed

11:28 at approximately 80% of this

11:31 sales in both the 23 and 24

11:32 data sets.

11:34 That figure rose to

11:37 approximately 68% for the

11:39 highest price 2025 sales.

11:41 The individual examples in

11:43 boston that make these

11:44 differences particularly.

11:46 Striking the globe highlighted

11:49 59 commonwealth app, which sold

11:51 for $21 million but carried an

11:55 million.

11:55 assessed value of $12.5

11:57 That's one of the reasons why

11:58 we're here today.

12:00 The underlying data set

12:01 contains properties where the

12:04 gap is even larger, including a

12:06 $15 million commonwealth avenue

12:08 sale assessed that approximate

12:08 .

12:09 Can you believe it?

12:11 $4.4 million.

12:13 Just say that again that $15

12:15 million commonwealth avenue

12:18 sale assessed that $4.4

12:18 million.

12:20 Today's hearing is an

12:21 opportunity to understand why

12:23 we are seeing that pattern.

12:25 Whether the comparison being

12:26 presented to us is an

12:29 appropriate way to evaluate

12:31 assessment equity and if there

12:33 is a problem, what changes the

12:35 city can make to ensure that

12:37 every property owner is treated

12:38 fairly and equitably?

12:39 Thank you.

12:40 mr chair.

12:41 Thank you.

12:42 Uh, councilor flynn.

12:46 Thank you, mr chair.

12:47 And thank you to.

12:49 Councilor cole pepper for

12:50 bringing this.

12:54 Debate before us.

12:56 It's incredibly important.

13:00 That we discuss it and learn as

13:00 much as we can.

13:03 So I do want to say thank you

13:06 to councilor cole pepper for

13:06 his leadership.

13:10 I want to say thank you to the

13:12 acting um, assessing

13:14 commissioner for for being here

13:14 as well.

13:17 Uh, commissioner wong, uh,

13:17 thank you.

13:20 And I do know you come from a

13:22 public service.

13:22 wonderful family dedicated to

13:24 So I want to acknowledge your

13:28 family's commitment to, um to

13:30 helping people in our city.

13:36 I want to make sure that

13:39 residents know exactly what the

13:40 rules are.

13:46 How taxes property taxes are

13:48 determined, how much the city

13:52 can increase property taxes

13:55 based on the increase of the

13:58 value of your house and also

14:01 want to ask and find out some

14:02 more information.

14:05 Why do some people's house

14:06 residents.

14:08 Such as reverend reverend cole

14:12 pepper mentioned um that have

14:13 decreased in value?

14:15 But I also know that some

14:17 people don't they haven't had

14:19 any increase in their property

14:22 tax and other people had

14:24 significant increases in their

14:25 property taxes.

14:28 I just want to I just want us

14:29 to be on the same page.

14:34 Um transparent, accountable,

14:36 ensuring that we're providing

14:37 positive leadership and

14:39 everybody knows what the rules

14:39 are.

14:41 So they're not surprised when

14:44 they see a tax bill at the

14:45 beginning of the year because

14:48 it it is impacting working

14:50 class families and seniors when

14:54 they see a 13% or 10% increase

14:56 in their taxes especially when

14:57 they're on fixed income.

15:00 Not sure how long we can

15:01 continue doing that to

15:01 residents.

15:07 Residents are struggling and a

15:09 13% tax increase or a 10% tax

15:11 increase over the last two

15:13 years and then another

15:15 potential increase.

15:18 It's devastating working class

15:18 families.

15:21 Uh, families on fixed income

15:23 and homeowners that made on

15:25 more than made it on like a

15:27 double um a two family because

15:30 they have to pass that tax

15:32 increase on to the residents

15:34 obviously on to the renters.

15:36 Those are some of the questions

15:37 I will ask.

15:38 But again want to say thank you

15:41 to the um, acting assistant

15:42 commissioner for being here.

15:43 Thank you, mr chair.

15:43 Okay.

15:44 thank you.

15:45 Councilor fitzgerald.

15:47 Thank you.

15:48 chair.

15:49 uh, I would like to.

15:49 Thank, uh, council.

15:50 Member for bringing.

15:50 this.

15:51 Forward as well.

15:53 Uh, and thank you to acting

15:54 commissioner hogan, uh, for

15:56 being here today to to educate

15:57 us on, uh, a little bit more

15:58 of this.

15:59 As you can imagine, we got lots

16:00 of calls in the last two years

16:01 when we had, uh, both, uh,

16:03 double digit increases in

16:05 property tax and I.

16:05 know for.

16:07 Myself in dorchester which is

16:08 predominantly middle and lower

16:10 class families, we got a lot

16:11 of uh incoming about their

16:13 taxes as they came in.

16:15 And so, um, it's something that

16:16 I know that it's easy to get

16:18 lost in the minutia of all the

16:19 numbers and details and I

16:21 believe when we asked this

16:23 question either earlier this

16:25 year oriented during last year,

16:27 uh, the answer we got is it's

16:29 more of an art than a science

16:30 and that that just doesn't.

16:32 Um, you know when you go to

16:33 constituents and tell them that

16:35 that that doesn't fly right.

16:36 And so what I hope to learn

16:38 today is uh, more of an

16:40 understanding about how uh,

16:42 they are applied, uh, how they

16:44 are applied fairly across all

16:45 uh, socioeconomic spectrums.

16:49 Um and uh really give help us

16:51 give a be able to give a better

16:54 answer uh to the community and

16:55 at least if maybe it won't be

16:56 the answer they want to hear or

16:58 maybe through this process we

16:59 can understand where we're

17:00 lacking and can fill in those

17:00 gaps.

17:02 So, uh, thank you very much for

17:02 being here to educate us.

17:03 Thank you jill.

17:05 Okay.

17:06 thank you very much.

17:09 I'm just, uh, briefly from the

17:09 from the chair.

17:12 Uh, you know, I think, uh, this

17:13 is a I want to thank

17:14 councilor culpeper for filing

17:14 this.

17:16 I don't think I've ever had to

17:18 learn so much new information

17:19 for one hearing.

17:21 Uh, you know, we talk about,

17:22 uh, I think we'll hear in the

17:25 hearing about, uh, vertical

17:27 equity, uh, which my

17:28 understanding of it is we have

17:30 we've achieved vertical equity

17:33 where, uh, the assessed price

17:36 of a home, uh, is in line with

17:38 the sale price across the board

17:39 and it's a you know, you're

17:40 going to find that either we're

17:42 assessing over or under within

17:43 a certain percentage of what

17:45 the sale price would be and it

17:46 doesn't matter what the value

17:47 of the home is.

17:49 Uh, I learned about regressive

17:49 city.

17:52 So if we have regressive city

17:54 what that means is we are

17:56 taxing lower value homes at a

17:58 higher proportional rate than

18:01 the than the the uh the higher

18:01 value homes.

18:03 So that means that the burden

18:05 is unfairly being placed on

18:06 lower value homes.

18:09 If we have progressivity we are

18:11 taxing the higher value homes

18:14 at a higher rate than the lower

18:15 value homes.

18:17 And so uh, you know, certainly

18:19 uh, you know, given boston's,

18:19 you.

18:20 know.

18:22 Troubled history, you know,

18:25 with uh, uh, discrimination and

18:28 institutional racism and with

18:29 practices like redlining you

18:31 read the the boston globe

18:32 editorial and you you think,

18:35 okay, this is another example

18:36 of uh, you know, there's this

18:39 is a regressive system that is

18:42 uh, we're allowing to harm low

18:43 you know, sort of low income

18:44 low value homeowners.

18:47 Uh, but I think when you dig a

18:48 little deeper it's the story is

18:49 not as clear.

18:51 Uh, you know, if you I think

18:53 ron roco was the commissioner

18:55 of assessing did it an analysis

18:58 and uh, if you look at the the

19:00 the the the system for the

19:02 whole city there is a slight

19:03 amount of regressive city so we

19:06 are taxing lower uh, value

19:08 homes at a slightly higher

19:10 level but that is that might

19:11 that means it would be

19:13 regressive if we took no

19:15 actions to remedy that.

19:17 And so number one is we have a

19:18 homestead exemption a

19:19 residential exemption which

19:21 allows people to write off

19:24 essentially like $350,000 if

19:25 I'm understanding this

19:27 correctly of their home value

19:30 which converts are in the tax

19:31 bills, they're actually

19:33 according to uh, mr account.

19:35 We're actually a progressive

19:35 city.

19:36 uh.

19:39 because that that that flat

19:41 amount that, you know,

19:43 overwhelmingly benefits lower

19:44 value homes.

19:46 So uh, I just I think there's

19:47 you know, this an incredibly

19:50 complex technical field and I

19:51 look forward to the

19:53 conversation and I thank my

19:55 colleagues for bringing this

19:57 discussion, uh, here and so I

19:58 don't see any of my colleagues

20:01 uh, so uh, with that said uh,

20:03 interim commissioner wong uh,

20:04 the floor is yours.

20:05 Thank you.

20:06 Councilor, to close.

20:09 Um.

20:10 you presented basically

20:11 everything.

20:12 I was close friends so.

20:13 But I'll reiterate everything

20:13 again.

20:14 Um.

20:17 good afternoon.

20:18 For the record, my name is

20:19 helen wong.

20:20 I am intern commissioner for

20:21 the city of boston department.

20:24 I'm here to discuss docket 0586

20:26 regarding my office's

20:27 assessment practices in

20:28 evaluating residential

20:29 properties.

20:31 This topic is deeply important

20:31 to my department.

20:34 My staff of over 50 live in

20:36 every neighborhood of boston

20:37 from east boston to hyde park.

20:39 They're in our neighborhoods

20:40 every day speaking with

20:42 residents and business owners

20:43 to ensure our property data is

20:45 accurate, fair and equitable.

20:50 Annually our department values

20:52 over 190,000 parcels and an

20:55 assessed valuation of over 295

20:56 billion property taxes

20:58 generated over 3.5 billion in

21:00 revenue for the city in fiscal

21:00 year 26.

21:02 My office is also responsible

21:04 for excise taxes on boats and

21:06 motor vehicles, administering

21:08 the pilot program and tax

21:08 agreements.

21:10 We also manage personal

21:11 exemptions such as the

21:12 residential exemption and

21:13 senior exemption programs.

21:18 Under state regulatory

21:19 guidelines, we are required to

21:21 inspect each property at least

21:22 once every ten years.

21:25 The primary goal of these