Education Committee

Tuesday, March 24, 2026, 2 p.m. (Boston time), Boston City Hall, 1 City Hall Square, Boston, MA 02201

Hearing on Docket #0166

Committee: Education Committee

Video of the meeting

On the agenda

Documents

Summary

The Education Committee, chaired by Councilor Julia Mejia, held a hearing on Docket 0166 regarding Boston Public Schools student athlete transfer and eligibility policies, sponsored by Councilor Gabriela Coletta Zapata. The hearing examined how the MIAA's Rule 57 and the Form 200 transfer eligibility process are applied, prompted by public concern over a specific case in which a Charlestown High student who transferred from Madison Park was ruled ineligible amid uninvestigated recruitment allegations. Public testimony included the student's BPS coach, an attorney reading statements from the student and his mother, and three of the student's teammates. BPS officials Samuel DePina (Deputy Superintendent of Operations) and Kevin McCarthy (Chief of Student Support) explained the Form 200 process, the Case Review Board, and the ongoing investigation, declining to answer case-specific questions while committing to provide data and process improvements. Councilors also raised issues of language access, due process, and whether an independent investigation should occur. No vote was taken; the matter was discussed.

Transcript

6:16 know.

11:40 And.

12:24 Be good.

12:27 okay, ethan, we're good to

12:27 start.

12:33 Um, for the record, my name is

12:35 julia mejia at large city

12:36 councilor and I'm the chair

12:37 of the boston city council's

12:38 committee on education.

12:42 Today is MARCH 24th, 2026 and

12:44 the exact time is 212.

12:46 This hearing is being recorded

12:48 and is also being live streamed

12:53 at boston.Gov/city council dash

12:55 tv and broadcast on 20 channel

12:59 eight rcn channel 82 files

13:00 channel 964.

13:02 Written comments MAY be sent to

13:07 the committee um email at scott

13:08 education@boston.Gov.

13:09 And it will be made part of the

13:11 record and available to all

13:11 councilors.

13:13 Public testimony will be taken

13:15 at the beginning, middle and

13:16 end of this hearing.

13:18 Individuals will be called in

13:20 the order in which they have

13:22 signed up and will have two

13:22 minutes to testify.

13:24 If you are interested in

13:25 testifying in person, please

13:27 add your name to the sign up

13:28 sheet near the entrance of the

13:28 chamber.

13:31 If you are looking to testify

13:32 virtually, please email our

13:35 central staff liaison ron

13:37 cobb@ron.Com at boston.Gov for

13:39 the link and your name will be

13:39 added to the list.

13:44 Today's hearing is on docket

13:45 0166 and order for a hearing

13:47 regarding boston public school

13:49 student athlete transfer and

13:50 eligibility policies.

13:53 This matter was sponsored by my

13:54 colleague councilor gabriel

13:56 colletta supporter and was

13:59 referred to my committee on

14:00 JANUARY 28th, 2026.

14:02 Today in order of arrival we

14:05 have councilor murphy,

14:06 councilor flynn,

14:08 councilor sabata,

14:09 councilor pepping.

14:09 councilor louijeune and

14:14 I have not received any letters

14:15 of absence as far as I know.

14:18 Um and so this hearing comes in

14:20 response to broader concerns

14:22 about how boston public schools

14:24 administrators student athlete

14:25 transfer and eligibility

14:28 processes look like recent um

14:29 public attention including

14:30 conversations across our

14:32 communities has raised concerns

14:34 about how these rules are

14:35 applied for many students

14:38 participation in sports um

14:39 attendance and engagement and

14:39 overall well-being.

14:42 At the same time, eligibility

14:44 decisions are shaped by both

14:45 local practices and external

14:46 standards including those set

14:48 by the massachusetts

14:49 interscholastic athletic

14:51 association where timelines and

14:52 procedures can carry

14:53 significant consequence.

14:55 Today's an opportunity to

14:57 examine how these policies are

14:59 implemented and how clearly

15:00 they are being communicated.

15:02 This is not about one single

15:03 case and I want to note that

15:04 for the record, but it's about

15:05 assuring that the system works

15:07 in a way that supports students

15:10 and does not unintentionally

15:10 disadvantage them.

15:13 And so with that I am going to

15:14 turn it over to the lead

15:16 sponsor for any opening remarks

15:19 and I will um, as my colleagues

15:21 if you have an opening remark

15:22 um, to turn on your light and

15:22 I'll call on you.

15:24 So, uh.

15:25 Counselors.

15:27 thank you.

15:28 Chair mahi, I want to thank you

15:29 and your team for your

15:30 flexibility and also for

15:31 ministration for for.

15:32 Being here.

15:33 We had to reschedule this due

15:36 to snow storm and technical

15:37 difficulties with that.

15:38 So just appreciate everyone's,

15:40 um, time today.

15:41 I wanna thank my colleagues for

15:42 being here and members of the

15:43 public.

15:44 Uh, this hearing is about

15:45 fairness, transparency and a

15:47 basic principle that students

15:48 should not lose opportunities

15:50 because of unclear processes.

15:52 For many of our young people,

15:54 athletics are not just an

15:55 extracurricular they are a

15:56 source of stability, belonging

15:57 ,mentorship and purpose.

15:59 When a student transfer schools

16:01 whether for academic, social or

16:03 family reasons they deserve a

16:05 process that is clear, timely

16:06 and fair with notice, support

16:09 and the opportunity to be heard

16:11 under meaa rule 57.

16:12 We know that students who

16:15 transfer are generally presumed

16:17 ineligible unless a form 200 is

16:19 approved or an exemption

16:19 applies.

16:21 But what we've learned is that

16:23 while the rule is clear, the

16:24 process of who gets cleared

16:27 under the form 200 is not at

16:28 the mia level.

16:30 There is no clearly defined

16:33 investigatory framework when

16:34 allegations of recruitment are

16:34 raised.

16:36 The system is largely compliant

16:39 driven with schools acting as

16:40 the primary gatekeepers and

16:42 formal review only happening

16:44 after the fact if it happens at

16:44 all.

16:46 Within dps we've heard concerns

16:48 about a lack of written

16:50 policies for support, unclear

16:51 timeline, limited communication

16:53 with families and questions

16:54 whether students are giving a

16:56 meaningful opportunity to

16:57 participate in decisions that

16:59 directly impact them.

17:01 This creates a troubling

17:03 dynamic where students

17:04 eligibility can be determined

17:06 based on allegations that MAY

17:07 not have been fully

17:09 investigated within a system

17:12 that is not clearly defined or

17:12 consistently applied.

17:14 And again, while we're not here

17:16 to relitigate any one case,

17:17 there's circumstances that

17:18 brought us here highlight

17:20 broader concerns delayed

17:22 communication, lack of parental

17:24 notice, questions about how

17:25 investigations are conducted

17:27 and whether students

17:28 particularly those with

17:30 additional needs are being

17:30 adequately supported through

17:31 the process.

17:33 At the end of the day this

17:35 cannot be about adult disputes,

17:36 internal dynamics or

17:38 institutional discretion.

17:40 We have a responsibility to

17:42 ensure that adult conflicts and

17:43 miscommunication or

17:45 inconsistent systems do not

17:46 have a lasting consequence on

17:48 our young people, especially

17:50 those who rely on school based

17:52 mentorship structure and

17:53 support and who need support

17:54 the most.

17:55 So today we're seeking flaherty

17:57 on how decisions are made.

17:59 What protections exist and what

18:00 changes are needed to ensure

18:02 that every student then is

18:03 treated fairly.

18:05 So I look forward to the

18:06 conversation and again thank

18:08 everybody for being here today.

18:08 thank you councilor glitter.

18:11 I see that both councilor flynn

18:13 and councilor murphy have their

18:13 hands.

18:14 Uh their lights on.

18:16 So we'll go first to

18:18 councilor murphy then followed

18:19 by councilor flynn.

18:21 And I also want to note for the

18:22 record that we have been joined

18:24 by district seven

18:24 councilor culpeper.

18:27 Councilor murphy, you have 30s.

18:29 Thank you.

18:30 Chair.

18:32 Um, happy we're here to have

18:33 this conversation.

18:34 Thank you for being here.

18:37 Boston public schools has an

18:38 obligation to fully comply with

18:40 the rules and regulations set

18:42 forth by the massachusetts

18:44 interscholastic athletic

18:44 association.

18:46 Um, obviously known as mia.

18:48 These rules are not optional

18:50 nor can they be selectively

18:50 applied.

18:52 They must be enforced

18:54 consistently, transparently and

18:55 without exception.

18:57 Any system that allows for

19:00 inconsistent interpretation,

19:01 selective enforcement or

19:03 procedural discretion that

19:06 varies from case to case risks

19:07 creating inequitable outcomes

19:07 for.

19:08 Our students.

19:10 When policies are applied

19:12 unevenly whether through delays

19:14 ,miscommunication or

19:16 discretionary decision making,

19:19 students not systems bear the

19:19 consequences.

19:21 It is unacceptable for a

19:23 student to lose access to

19:24 educational or athletic

19:26 opportunities due to adult

19:27 error, administrative

19:29 inconsistency or a failure to

19:31 uniformly follow established

19:31 rules.

19:33 Boston public schools must

19:36 ensure that all eligibility

19:37 determinations are handled with

19:39 rigor, flaherty and fairness

19:41 and that no student is

19:44 disadvantaged by a process that

19:45 lacks consistency or

19:46 accountability.

19:48 So looking forward to this

19:50 conversation and really kind

19:53 of taking a deep dive into how

19:54 we are applying the rules that

19:56 we know are there and if we're

19:57 doing them consistently.

19:58 Thank you, councilor murphy.

20:00 Thank you, councilor flynn.

20:01 You have the floor.

20:03 Thank you, MADAM Chair.

20:07 I want to echo the comments

20:08 of councilor murphy.

20:09 It's about fairness.

20:12 It's about ensuring that our

20:14 student athletes have the

20:16 opportunity to participate in a

20:19 program and athletics has as

20:21 the father of a child that

20:23 played sports at wps for for

20:24 four years.

20:26 I know how important sports are

20:28 for a student.

20:33 Um but I do think the um office

20:35 of athletics needs to enforce

20:38 the rules consistently, fairly

20:40 and provide every child, every

20:41 student an opportunity to play

20:42 sports.

20:45 they do have to follow the

20:46 rules of the meaa.

20:47 Thank you, MADAM Chair.

20:48 Thank you.

20:50 Councilor flynn, I see that

20:51 councilor louijeune light is on

20:53 so you now have the floor.

20:55 Thank you to everyone for being

20:55 here.

20:56 Um, for the.

20:57 Connections that I've had with

20:59 folks about these issues.

21:00 I for me, I think it's about

21:01 flaherty about understanding

21:02 the rules and how they apply.

21:04 So I look forward to hearing

21:06 um, those rules I think that

21:08 these are uh, difficult

21:09 conversations especially when

21:10 people are.

21:11 Not allowed to play a sport

21:13 that they really care about.

21:15 And it's important that we have

21:16 rules in place that make sense

21:18 for everyone and that make sure

21:20 that everyone is um uh is

21:21 acting with integrity.

21:24 And so I look forward to um,

21:25 hearing uh, from the panelists

21:27 today about how we ensure that

21:27 .

21:28 Thank you so much.

21:30 Thank you, councilor louijeune.

21:32 councilor prepping then

21:32 Um, we're going to go next to

21:33 councilor culpepper.

21:33 followed by

21:34 Thank you, MADAM Chair.

21:37 And thank you guys for being

21:38 here for me.

21:40 For me this is a learning

21:41 journey for me.

21:42 I want to know what the process

21:42 is.

21:43 I want to know how we can

21:44 strengthen it moving forward

21:45 and being able to catch up with

21:46 what my colleagues have been

21:48 doing and as a former athlete

21:50 just always want to be an

21:51 advocate for for our students

21:52 across the city.

21:53 So thank you so much for being

21:53 here.

21:54 Looking forward to asking

21:54 questions.

21:57 Thank you councilor for being

21:58 councilor culpepper.

22:00 Thank you, MADAM Chair.

22:03 I'm not going 10s.

22:08 I'll make it quick and.

22:09 then hurry up.

22:12 Good to see you.

22:12 Uh.

22:17 Director grayson and, uh,

22:20 deputy superintendent uh, DR.

22:25 Pina as one who played, uh, on

22:26 championship basketball teams

22:28 at english when we won the

22:30 state championship the next

22:32 year we won the city

22:33 championship.

22:37 I understand about, uh, my

22:38 rules and how they work or how

22:39 they don't work.

22:42 Um, but I do think that when

22:44 the policies are not clearly

22:46 communicated and in our days

22:48 there was no transfer if you

22:50 went to english, you had

22:51 english.

22:53 It wasn't because the schools

22:55 became one body and so there

22:57 was nothing about no one for

22:58 english would ever transfer to

23:00 dorchester or no one for

23:01 dorchester would ever transfer

23:04 to brighton because we became a

23:04 body.

23:06 And when the rules change and

23:08 it's not clear to the students,

23:09 I think it's a soon to lose.

23:12 So we want to hear from you.

23:13 Good to see you again.

23:16 Hopefully the the policies

23:18 policies can be developed that

23:20 work for the students and not

23:20 against them.

23:22 Thank you, MADAM Chair.

23:25 thank you, councilor culpeper.

23:28 Um, so just for a few

23:29 housekeeping, uh, things that

23:31 I'd like to just put on the

23:32 record, I'm going to have my

23:34 council colleague come up with

23:36 being, um, facilitate because

23:37 I'm going to be stepping out.

23:37 Lucky you.

23:38 all for.

23:41 Like 15, 20 minutes, but I'll

23:41 be back.

23:43 Um, and.

23:44 So he'll be taking over.

23:45 So I just want people to know

23:46 that I'll be stepping out and

23:48 and um, but before I go, we

23:50 want to start off, um, at the

23:52 sponsors request with public

23:53 testimony.

23:54 So we're going to call down

23:58 hugh coleman and die and

24:02 latimer la martina deanna la

24:04 martina just to get that right

24:05 .

24:06 So okay hugh.

24:08 Come on down.

24:10 Then followed by.

24:14 Diane la martina.

24:15 Oh yes.

24:16 And you.

24:17 Have two minutes.

24:18 Thank you.

24:19 uh.

24:20 Hello everyone.

24:22 Uh, hugh coleman I've been here

24:23 before.

24:24 I'm a long time resident

24:25 of boston.

24:26 Uh, boston.

24:28 Born and raised here in boston.

24:29 Uh, tend to boston public

24:31 schools my entire life.

24:33 Um, after graduating from

24:35 charlestown high school I went

24:35 to bowdoin college.

24:38 Uh, and I had a four year

24:38 career there.

24:41 Um, and came back here to be an

24:41 educator.

24:43 so for the past 24 years I've

24:45 been a boston public school

24:45 teacher.

24:48 Um, administrator and

24:48 basketball coach.

24:51 Um, I'm here today.

24:53 Um, specifically, uh, to speak

24:57 about how the uh, um, flaherty

25:00 um, of the rules applied this

25:02 particular year to uh, young

25:04 man that, uh, had the honor

25:07 of being in care of um this

25:09 young man did transfer from

25:11 another school, um, from

25:12 madison park high school.

25:15 Uh, but his transfer was based

25:18 primarily on the fact that his

25:21 academic, uh, needs he's, uh,

25:22 special education student.

25:26 Um, he's also a student athlete

25:27 ,but his academic and social

25:29 emotional needs were not being

25:29 met.

25:32 Um, at madison that he felt his

25:34 family felt so to exercise

25:36 their right to transfer to, uh,

25:36 school.

25:38 Um, that would better provide

25:40 his support for his needs.

25:43 Um, he ended up getting

25:45 assigned to charlestown high

25:48 school and from there, um, you

25:50 know, once he was in my care I

25:51 took the, uh, privilege

25:52 of working with him.

25:55 Uh, unfortunately because, uh,

25:57 the school he came from madison

25:59 park high school coach, uh,

26:02 felt that he left, uh, for

26:03 athletic reasons.

26:06 Um, without doing proper

26:08 investigation, meeting with the

26:08 parent.

26:09 Uh, really getting to

26:11 understand why the young men

26:11 left.

26:13 They made those assumptions.

26:14 They made those assertions.

26:16 Uh, they even made an

26:19 allegation, uh, that myself, uh

26:21 ,and someone else from uh,

26:22 madison park high school, uh,

26:24 worked together to recruit the