Roxbury's neighborhood council says the Wu administration is bypassing it to fill a land oversight committee. The council backed the RNC 10-0 in July
A 2004 master plan gives the Roxbury Neighborhood Council and Roxbury's elected officials the nominations; the city posted an open application instead. Culpepper has asked the city to stop the search and explain its legal basis.
Members of the Roxbury Neighborhood Council say the Wu administration is sidestepping their role in choosing members of the committee that oversees development of former state-owned land in Roxbury, the Dorchester Reporter reported on Wednesday.
The dispute
The Roxbury Strategic Master Plan, signed in 2004 under Mayor Thomas Menino, created the Roxbury Strategic Master Plan Oversight Committee to select and approve projects on large parcels in the neighborhood. Under the plan, the neighborhood council and officials elected to represent Roxbury nominate members, and the mayor appoints from that list, the Reporter reported.
In October, the city posted an application form for residents seeking two vacancies on the oversight committee. In an Oct. 30 letter to the mayor, the neighborhood council's chair wrote that "it is unambiguous and clear that the RNC and Roxbury's elected officials own the nomination process." The letter asked 14 questions, including whether the administration believes it cannot follow the plan's governance rules or has chosen not to. Nearly two weeks later, it had not received a response, the Reporter reported.
According to the letter, city officials told the group in meetings on Oct. 27 and 29 that the city's Law Department had found the 2004 agreement not legally binding, and that the mayor, elected citywide, counts as a Roxbury elected official for nominations. A spokesperson for the mayor did not respond to the Reporter before its deadline.
Advertisement
City Councilor Miniard Culpepper, whose district includes Roxbury, wrote to the city on Oct. 29 asking it to suspend the search and to explain in writing "the legal basis for any determination that the master plan's nomination procedures are optional," the Reporter reported.
It is the second dispute this year over the plan. In January, the administration decided to use Parcel P3 on Columbus Avenue, long planned for a development team, for a new Madison Park Technical Vocational High School campus. Critics say the plan required a community process led by the oversight committee first.
What the council has done
July 22: Recognizing the RNC, 10-0. Culpepper's resolution recognizing the Roxbury Neighborhood Council passed with 10 votes; City Councilors Gabriela Coletta Zapata and Henry Santana were absent and City Councilor Sharon Durkan was not present (docket 1430). Speaking for it, Culpepper said the master plan includes "a role for the RNC and the nomination process of members" of the oversight committee, and warned that current members had served past the plan's three-year terms as the city moved toward appointments (watch at 2:44:45). "We cannot selectively rely on the [Roxbury] Strategic Master Plan when it is convenient," he said (watch at 2:45:20).
City Councilor Julia Mejia, a co-sponsor, said the resolution recognizes the RNC's role under Article 50 of the zoning code in reviewing development (watch at 2:46:28).
Advertisement
Jan. 28: Parcel P3. Culpepper's resolution calling for more transparency and community engagement on Parcel P3 and the Madison Park project passed 12-0, with Durkan voting present (docket 0170).
Resolutions put the council on record but don't bind the administration. Under Article 50, neighborhood councils like the RNC advise on projects; they don't approve them. The oversight committee's powers come from the 2004 plan, whose legal force is the point in dispute.
What's next
The application period for the two seats has not been reported closed. The council's next meeting is Nov. 18. Our earlier story covers the Madison Park rebuild's project manager shortlist.