On My Block · Boston Politics

ReparationsCity Council

Boston's reparations task force weighs its next step after the city dropped the Tufts slavery study

The task force says the colonial period can't be skipped, and historians offered ways to replace the research. A council order filed by Culpepper in September asks the city for the contracts, the $335,000 refund and a timeline.

Members of the Boston Reparations Task Force are debating how to cover the city's colonial-era history of slavery now that the city has dropped a Tufts University study of that period, the Dorchester Reporter reported.

The task force, created in December 2022, commissioned Tufts to research 1620 to 1940 and Northeastern University to cover 1940 to 2020. The city and Tufts canceled their contract in September after concerns about the academic and citation practices of the project's former lead researcher, and Tufts returned the $335,000 contract amount, according to a council order filed in September. The Reporter reported the researcher was found to have falsified past academic research.

What the task force heard

At a recent meeting, historians and an archaeologist who have studied slavery in Boston offered ways forward, the Reporter reported. One proposal was a conference of researchers from churches, schools, museums and universities already working on the subject, with a report to follow. An archaeologist said her team is mapping where the roughly 2,300 people enslaved in colonial Boston lived and has found deeds for 356 properties owned by enslavers.

Task force chair Joseph Feaster said the group will not yet make public the Northeastern study. "Every single person has said that if you're going to do reparations for slavery, you cannot not include the period in which slavery happened," he said, according to the Reporter.

Members also differed on the project's aim. Task force member Nyheim Way, president of the Sons and Daughters of Freedman, said, "I want to be clear that this is not a history project," and that the history is needed to measure harms to descendants of people enslaved in the United States, the Reporter reported.

Massachusetts ended slavery in 1783. The task force's charge is to document harms to Black Bostonians during and after slavery and recommend remedies to the city.

What the council asked for

City Councilor Miniard Culpepper filed an order under Section 17F, the council's power to request information from the mayor, on the task force's research, spending and plans (docket 1855). The council passed it by voice vote on Sept. 30 without debate (watch at 1:41:15).

The order notes that Northeastern's report is finished but not public, and that no timeline has been given for finishing the earlier research, starting community engagement or issuing recommendations. It asks for:

  • The status of every report and deliverable, and a timeline from December 2022 on, including deadlines missed and payments.
  • The requests for proposals, contracts, progress reports and invoices for both research teams, and how each team was evaluated.
  • When the city first learned of concerns about the former lead researcher, and whether Tufts disclosed them.
  • Any Tufts work that can still be verified or used, and who owns it.
  • An accounting of the $335,000 refund, where it is held and how the administration proposes to use it.

The order asked for answers within a week of the mayor's receipt. Section 17F responses often take longer, and the council has a separate order pending on unanswered 17F requests.

What's next

The task force has not announced a replacement for the Tufts research or a date to release the Northeastern report. Culpepper has raised the task force's work in council budget hearings this year as well (watch at 17:31).

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime