Question 7 fails by about 32,000 votes. Boston, which it wouldn't have covered, voted 69% yes
The Associated Press projected the lot-size measure's defeat Friday afternoon, nearly three days after the polls closed. What the result means here, and the council's own lot-size item that still has no hearing.
Question 7, the statewide measure that would have let single-family homes be built on 5,000-square-foot lots, has failed. The Associated Press projected Friday afternoon, Nov. 6, nearly three days after the polls closed, that "no" had won, with 50.6% to 49.4% and about 99% of the vote counted, CBS Boston reported. The margin was 32,322 votes out of more than 2.5 million cast. These are unofficial results; the state has not certified them.
It was the closest of the nine questions on the ballot and the last to be decided. When our Thursday story ran, "no" led by about 29,000 votes with about 94% counted.
What it would have done, and why Boston was left out
The measure would have amended Chapter 40A, the state Zoning Act, so cities and towns could not require more than 5,000 square feet for a single-family home on a lot with public water and sewer and at least 50 feet of street frontage, WBUR reported. Boston has its own zoning law and is not covered by Chapter 40A, so the result changes nothing about what can be built here.
Boston's vote still mattered to the count. The city's unofficial results, last updated at 3:46 a.m. Nov. 4 with all 275 precincts in, show 119,998 yes and 53,286 no, or 69.25% yes (city results). By our arithmetic, that is a net "yes" margin of 66,712 votes from Boston alone. Combined with the AP's final statewide margin, it means "no" won the rest of the state by roughly 99,000 votes. Both figures are unofficial, and they come from counts taken at different times.
Advertisement
What the two sides said
Adam Chapdelaine, executive director of the Massachusetts Municipal Association, which represents the state's cities and towns, said voters recognized that "a top-down, one-size-fits-all mandate would have negative consequences in communities," GBH News reported. Jesse Kanson-Benanav of Abundant Housing MA said more than 1.2 million residents had voted for the measure, GBH reported. There was no formal opposition committee.
Pre-election polls missed how close it would be. A UMass Amherst/WCVB poll had 65% yes and 21% no, while a Suffolk University/Boston Globe poll found about 41% yes and 40% no, WBUR reported.
Is a recount possible?
A ballot question recount petition is allowed only when the margin is no more than 0.5% of the votes cast, as Boston.com reported last week. On about 2.5 million votes, that is roughly 12,500 votes. The final margin is more than twice that.
What our records add
Boston's own lot-size item is still waiting. City Councilor Brian Worrell's June order for a hearing on eliminating minimum lot sizes in District 4 (docket 1103) has been in the Planning, Development and Transportation Committee since June 3, now 160 days, with no hearing posted. When he filed it, Worrell said District 4 zoning requires lots of 3,000 to 7,000 square feet, and that more than 60 vacant city-owned lots there fall below the 3,000-square-foot minimum (watch at 4:55:14). In Boston, that kind of change goes through the city's Zoning Commission, not the ballot.
Advertisement
The council took no position on Question 7 (our Oct. 27 story).
What's next
Nov. 18: Boston's deadline to certify its official results, which will add provisional, overseas and late mail ballots.
Early December: Statewide certification of all nine questions.
Monday, Nov. 9: The Wu administration proposed its own changes to the city's affordable housing rules for developers. Our story explains what the council can do about them.