On My Block · Boston Politics

TransportationCity Council

Flynn files a hearing order and a resolution against congestion pricing, which Boston has not proposed

Wu said in October the city is studying New York's tolls but has no plan. Flynn's filings for Wednesday ask the council to hold a hearing and to go on record opposing the idea now.

City Councilor Ed Flynn wants the City Council to weigh in on congestion pricing before the Wu administration decides anything. He has filed two items for the council's Wednesday, Nov. 18 meeting:

  • An order for a hearing on congestion pricing in Boston (docket 2161; order).
  • A resolution stating "That the Boston City Council opposes congestion pricing in the City of Boston" (docket 2162; resolution).

Congestion pricing charges drivers a fee to enter a busy zone at certain hours. New York began charging most cars to enter lower Manhattan in January 2025.

Where the idea stands

No congestion pricing proposal is before the council, based on the records we track. Mayor Michelle Wu told the MBTA Advisory Board on Oct. 20 that her team had been in touch with New York and that a team of city and state workers would visit to learn how its system works, we reported. Wu said then that the city had no concrete plan. Gov. Maura Healey said the timing was wrong, citing affordability.

The city's climate plan commits to studying ways to discourage driving into Boston, including parking fees, tolls and congestion fees, according to Northeastern University.

Flynn's case

The two filings share the same findings. Flynn argues that:

  • A fee would fall hardest on lower- and middle-income workers who drive because late-night and bus service is limited, and would "disproportionately impact communities of color."
  • MBTA ridership remains below pre-pandemic levels, and the transit system is not ready to absorb drivers pushed off the road.
  • Boston relies on property taxes for more than 70% of its revenue and is exposed to falling office values, citing a 2024 Tufts and Boston Policy Institute study that estimated losses of $1.7 billion to $2.1 billion. He says the city should show "fiscal discipline" before seeking new revenue.
  • Prices are rising faster than wages. He cites Boston-area consumer price data through September: overall prices up 3.8% from a year earlier, energy up 21.7% and gasoline up 38.3%.

Those are Flynn's figures and characterizations. Supporters of congestion pricing say it cuts traffic and pollution and raises money for transit. NBC Boston reported in October that New York's program brought in more than $550 million in net revenue in its first year and cut vehicles entering the zone by 11%.

What our records show

Flynn's votes this term line up with his filings. He was the lone no vote on Feb. 25 when the council adopted a resolution backing continued funding for the MBTA's fare-free bus program, 12-1 (docket 0425). On Oct. 21 he and City Councilor Erin Murphy voted against accepting a $3.25 million regional grant for new Bluebikes e-bikes (docket 1883), which passed 10-2.

A search of council meeting transcripts on this site found one mention of congestion pricing this year, during public testimony at an April 22 transportation hearing (watch at 1:45:51).

What's next

  • Wednesday, Nov. 18, noon: hearing orders are usually referred to a committee. A resolution can be adopted the same day if the council suspends its rules; a single objection sends it to committee.
  • No date has been set for the New York visit, and the administration has not said when its study will be done.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime