On My Block · Boston Politics

Public safetyBudget

Firefighters say screening a third of their union each year would cost about $585,000. The city's labor adviser says it belongs at the bargaining table

At a Ways and Means hearing on health screenings for police, fire and EMS, union leaders described paying for scans through fundraising and outside grants. The order, which 12 of 13 councilors sponsor, stays in committee as next year's budget approaches.

Boston's firefighters, police detectives and EMS workers told the City Council's Ways and Means Committee on Tuesday that health screenings for their members have depended on union fundraising, a lapsed federal grant and a hospital partnership, and asked the city to pay for them directly.

The hearing, chaired by City Councilor Benjamin Weber, took up an order from City Councilors Erin Murphy and Ed Flynn on city funding for health screenings and wellness support for first responders (docket 1917). Twelve of the 13 councilors sponsor it. The hearing ran a little over two hours (watch from the start). Quotes are from the city's caption record.

Why the order was filed

Murphy said she filed it after the police detectives' union told her it raised about $50,000 and put in another $60,000 of its own money to screen members, with no city contribution. "Our police officers should not have to depend on fundraising to access appropriate preventative health screenings," she said (watch at 8:46).

Flynn said he offered three budget amendments last cycle to fund screenings and wellness programs; the council backed the one for EMS and not those for police and fire, he said (watch at 10:48).

What the firefighters' union asked for

The president of Boston Firefighters Local 718 said the federal grant that paid for early-detection scans for about eight years was not renewed last year, and that the city does not separately fund occupational cancer, cardiac or mental health screenings for firefighters (watch at 58:06). A round of screenings paid for with help from Dana-Farber found that 58% of the firefighters screened had results that needed follow-up with a doctor, he said, and cancers were detected (watch at 1:01:08).

His math: about $1,000 per screening, 1,600 members, a third of them screened each year, or roughly $585,000 a year. He compared that with nearly $3 million for one late-stage cancer treatment (watch at 1:03:14). He also said the union "will make zero concessions" if the issue is pushed into contract talks (watch at 1:04:16).

What the administration said

Louis Mandarini, the mayor's senior adviser for labor policy, said benefits like these are usually set through collective bargaining with nearly 50 unions, and that differences between contracts are part of that process. "The patchwork is unavoidable," he said (watch at 44:49). City Councilor Miniard Culpepper said screenings "should be funded by the city" rather than through union fundraising and outside gifts, and also raised firefighters' turnout gear, which he said contains cancer-causing chemicals (watch at 41:15).

What's next

Hearings don't end in votes; the order stays in Ways and Means. Several councilors said the place to settle it is the next city budget. The mayor files the fiscal 2028 budget in the spring, and the council can amend it before it passes in June. Our earlier story covers the firefighter cancer screening gap.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime