On My Block · Boston Politics

SchoolsCity Council

Former School Committee member tells councilors she was pressured to vote yes; hybrid model gets a hearing

At Tuesday's Education Committee hearing, most councilors who spoke backed an elected board, but Weber and others asked how to keep money out and whether it would help students. No one from the administration testified. A working session is set for Nov. 25.

A former member of the appointed Boston School Committee told city councilors on Tuesday that she felt pressure from City Hall and central office staff to vote yes. She suggested a hybrid board, part elected and part appointed, as a place to start. Most of the councilors who spoke said they back some kind of elected board, but several still had open questions: how big, how chosen, and how to keep big money out.

The three-hour Education Committee hearing on Nov. 17 was on City Councilor Julia Mejia's order asking how best to set up an elected School Committee (docket 2044). No one from the Wu administration or Boston Public Schools testified. One advocate on the panel noted that the mayor's office had not come (watch at 1:51:11). Mejia chaired from her phone after her internet connection failed.

The former member's account

Lorna Rivera, a UMass Boston professor who directs the Gastón Institute, was appointed by Mayor Marty Walsh in 2018 and served until July 2021 (watch at 16:15). She said that between a proposal and a vote, members faced "phone calls, messages, meetings" from city hall or central office staff, and that she "always felt this pressure to approve" as one of the few members who dissented (watch at 19:30). She said some members abstained on close votes "rather than voting their conscience" (watch at 20:02).

Asked by City Councilor Brian Worrell how a board overseeing a $1.7 billion budget should be built, Rivera said "a hybrid model maybe... the best way to get started," keeping the mayor accountable for the budget (watch at 50:15). She suggested using the nine council districts for elected seats so the city would not have to draw new lines (watch at 51:51). She called the members' stipend "very low" for what she described as a second job (watch at 54:28).

The committee also played earlier recorded testimony from John Nucci, a former city councilor who was president of the elected School Committee from 1985 to 1989. He said it was the elected board that hired the city's first Black superintendent and that a federal judge cited when returning control of the schools to the city (watch at 32:52).

Where councilors stood

  • Mejia said the appointed board has given the city "budget deficits," worse outcomes and more unanimous votes, and called the hearing a chance "to expand democracy to fix a dysfunctional system" (watch at 5:53).
  • Council President Liz Breadon said the council backed an elected board five years ago, and that the question now is whether it should be fully elected or a hybrid. She said both have merit (watch at 9:41).
  • Ed Flynn: "I support an elected school committee," though he said putting one in place would be a challenge (watch at 13:32). He had left before his turn to ask questions.
  • Worrell, a co-sponsor, said residents should have "a real seat at the table" (watch at 11:52).
  • Miniard Culpepper recalled the elected board of his student days at English High. He asked Rivera whether the appointed board raises civil rights questions, including under the 14th Amendment (watch at 1:02:50).
  • Benjamin Weber said he favored a hybrid when he ran. He pointed to Chicago's first school board elections, where he said outside money was heavy, and asked whether studies show elected boards improve student results (watch at 1:03:54). Rivera said the research is mixed (watch at 1:09:15).
  • John FitzGerald said he was not on the council for the last vote and asked what went wrong when Boston last elected its board (watch at 44:20).

City Councilor Ruthzee Louijeune and City Councilor Erin Murphy attended part of the hearing. Co-sponsor Henry Santana sent a letter of absence.

The advocates' panel

A parent from the group QUEST, the Boston Teachers Union's political director and a co-chair of the 2021 ballot question committee all backed an elected board. The co-chair said the appointed board has never voted down an action item since at least 1994 (watch at 1:39:28). We have not checked that figure against the board's record. She proposed a "majority elected hybrid": nine members elected from council districts, plus perhaps a student and three mayoral appointees (watch at 1:54:53). In 2021, 79% of voters backed an elected board in a nonbinding question.

Following our usual practice, we do not name residents who testified during public comment.

What's next

Hearing orders usually stay in committee. The next step is a working session Wednesday, Nov. 25, at 10 a.m. on the council's home rule petition (docket 0162). As filed, it would create a 13-member board: nine members elected by district and four citywide, phased in over two elections, as we reported. A petition needs the council's vote, the mayor's signature and the Legislature's approval. Mayor Michelle Wu rejected the council's 2023 petition.

Meanwhile, the current appointed board meets at 6 p.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18, to continue its review of the plan to close three schools, including Charlestown High (agenda). It is scheduled to vote on Dec. 2.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime