On My Block · Boston Politics

SchoolsOversight

At the BPS contracting hearing, school officials admit telling the state a pass-through payment was a one-off was a "misstep"

Councilors pressed the BPS finance chief for three hours on the Inspector General's report. Officials wouldn't say who approved the payments, Flynn called it public corruption, and the city's finance watchdog said BPS accounts for about half the contract dollars it reviews.

For almost three hours on Thursday, Nov. 12, the City Council's Post-Audit Committee questioned Boston Public Schools officials about the state Inspector General's August report, which found the district spent at least $857,261 improperly or in violation of procurement law between 2018 and 2024. City Councilor John FitzGerald chaired the hearing on the order he filed with City Councilors Benjamin Weber and Julia Mejia (docket 1716). City Councilors Ed Flynn and Erin Murphy also took part.

The administration sent BPS Chief Financial Officer David Bloom and a senior adviser for operations. Opening for the district, the adviser said the findings "were deeply troubling" and represent "a standard of operations that is completely unacceptable," adding, "We're not here today to make any excuses" (watch at 12:56).

"Not a standalone occurrence"

The report says that after the city's Finance Commission flagged a pass-through payment in 2023, BPS officials, including the chief of finance at the time, told the Inspector General an internal review found it was a one-time event. Weber asked how that happened (watch at 21:40). The adviser said Bloom was not the CFO then and called it "a misstep on our part. It was not a standalone occurrence" (watch at 22:41).

Officials described the practice: facilities staff, finding the bidding process "too cumbersome," had vendors with contracts for one kind of work pay other, unauthorized subcontractors, adding a markup (watch at 15:28). They said the district reviewed more than 900 payments during a 10-day pause after the report, found about 13 with problems and no pass-throughs (watch at 28:52), and is working to recover about $77,000 in markups (watch at 35:30).

Bloom said BPS failed twice: in what the report found, and in how it explained its changes since 2023. "We did a bad job of working with the finance commission, working with the inspector general's office, working with this body," he said (watch at 1:10:31).

Who approved it

Flynn and Murphy asked repeatedly who authorized the payments. Officials said they would not discuss personnel matters in public and pointed to new operations leadership (watch at 36:00, watch at 41:36).

Murphy asked about a finding that a former employee who moved to Connecticut kept working for BPS while paid through a vendor, at a cost of $13,139.35 in markups. Asked if that was acceptable, an official answered, "Absolutely not" (watch at 43:06). Murphy also noted the report says its review was not exhaustive (watch at 38:04).

Flynn said he had sent the report to the state Attorney General. "It's public corruption as far as I'm concerned," he said (watch at 31:25). Asked whether any outside criminal investigation is underway, the answer was "Not that we know of" (watch at 1:12:03). Bloom said the Inspector General's office makes referrals to the Attorney General when it finds them appropriate (watch at 1:16:38). When the report came out, Inspector General Jeffrey Shapiro said investigators found no evidence of fraud or criminal conduct, WBUR reported.

Audits and a dashboard

Mejia asked whether BPS would support an annual independent procurement audit with public findings before each budget. Bloom said it would depend on the details, noting such audits can cost "hundreds of thousands" of dollars (watch at 54:17). Asked whether BPS has a public dashboard tracking audit recommendations, he said, "I don't believe we do," and that he is accountable for carrying them out (watch at 56:19).

The second panel

Matt Cahill, executive director of the Finance Commission, said his office reviewed more than 500 advertised city contracts worth over $500 million last year, about half of that value from BPS, and credited Bloom with being responsive (watch at 1:57:41). Steve Poftak, president of the Boston Municipal Research Bureau, cited a 2025 consultant's finding that 86% of BPS contracts began before they were approved (watch at 1:56:11) and suggested an ombudsman for vendors with payment problems (watch at 2:09:23). A councilor said the Inspector General was invited and declined (watch at 2:00:42).

One person testified, asking for a longer follow-up hearing. The order stays in committee. Our Nov. 2 story covers the district's written response.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime