The $798,000 e-bike grant keeps Bluebikes rides at 10 cents a minute; Flynn says he can't back it without a safety plan
Officials said Tuesday the state grant covers most of a $1.3 million subsidy that lowers e-bike fares for members. It buys no bikes or stations. Murphy, a no vote on the last e-bike grant, said she would support this one.
The $798,000 grant for "e-bike subsidies" that the City Council's transportation committee heard on Tuesday would not buy bikes or build stations. It would cover part of what Bluebikes cities pay to keep e-bike rides cheaper for members, city officials said. City Councilor Ed Flynn said he could not support it unless the city deals with e-bike safety, and pressed for a helmet requirement.
The order (docket 2083) is on the council's Wednesday, Nov. 18 agenda among "matters recently heard for possible action." Committee chair Sharon Durkan said at the end of the hearing that she hoped to move it at the next meeting (watch at 1:08:31). When the order was filed, the mayor's letter said only that the money "would fund support for e-bike subsidies for the system."
How the subsidy works
Kim Foltz of the city's Transportation Department, who testified for the bike share program, laid it out:
- Lyft, which operates Bluebikes, charges the cities 17 cents a minute for e-bike use. Standard members pay 10 cents a minute and income-eligible members 7 cents. The cities pay the difference (watch at 12:18).
- The subsidy will cost about $1.3 million systemwide in fiscal 2027. The MassDOT grant, which the Metropolitan Area Planning Council applied for on behalf of the member cities, covers $798,000. That leaves about $502,000, split by each city's share of the system. Boston's share is about $291,000, which Foltz said will come from Bluebikes sponsorship and rider revenue, not taxes (watch at 13:56).
- The grant "doesn't support any additional new stations," she said in answer to City Councilor Erin Murphy (watch at 16:05).
The system in numbers, as presented
- About 5,600 bikes, including about 1,500 e-bikes, and 363 stations in Boston (watch at 8:24).
- Close to 5 million trips systemwide this year, about 4.7 million by Foltz's estimate (watch at 10:02).
- E-bikes are 12% to 13% of the fleet but account for about 30% of trips. Income-eligible members take close to half their trips on e-bikes (watch at 10:40).
- The city's 100-station expansion has about 17 stations left, most in the Back Bay, where public meetings have not yet been held (watch at 17:09). Foltz said coverage is still thin in coastal and southern Dorchester, Hyde Park and West Roxbury (watch at 33:46).
The safety exchange
Murphy voted against a separate $3.25 million Bluebikes e-bike grant on Oct. 21 (our story). On Tuesday she asked about stations taking up parking and placing them in parks, and said she was "looking forward to supporting" this one (watch at 21:29).
Advertisement
Flynn, who also voted no in October, said he has filed proposals to regulate e-bikes and to ban e-bikes and mopeds from third-party food delivery (watch at 22:00). He cited emergency room doctors and a reported 173% rise in e-bike injuries, and asked whether the city could require helmets on bikes it sponsors (watch at 25:41). Foltz said helmets are part of the Bluebikes user agreement but are not required by state law for riders 17 and older (watch at 24:38). She said the city's coming Vision Zero action report notes that the city lacks detailed data on e-bike and other micromobility injuries (watch at 25:10).
"We're putting more e-bikes out on the street without addressing public safety and public health," Flynn said. "I don't support that" (watch at 30:03).
Foltz said Bluebikes e-bikes are pedal-assist bikes whose motors stop helping above 18 mph (watch at 29:31). She said Bluebikes riders reported 61 incidents, not all of them crashes, in two years and more than 9.3 million trips. More than half of those were on e-bikes, which she called disproportionate to the fleet. She still described Bluebikes as "tremendously safe" (watch at 31:07).
Flynn and Durkan then disagreed over how much more time he should get for questions (watch at 32:13). Durkan noted later that Bluebikes e-bikes are Class 1 bikes, which she said do not move as fast as many other e-bikes and scooters (watch at 34:51).
What's next
If the order is reported out of committee, the full council votes. Durkan also told colleagues she plans to ask them to "suspend and pass" more Bluebikes grants she expects before year's end, meaning a vote the day they arrive, without a hearing (watch at 1:09:04). Any one councilor can block that and send a grant to committee. The same hearing covered the 500-shelter street furniture contract; our story has those details.