On My Block · Boston Politics

HousingCity Council

Bad landlords list would name about 100 properties, city says, but it has 'concerns' about the penalties

Inspections officials told a council committee Monday that the city never put a 2012 chronic offender registry into practice. They want to set the list's thresholds themselves and are wary of barring listed landlords from zoning relief.

The city's Inspectional Services Department expects a public "bad landlords list" would name about 100 properties at most. But the Wu administration has "some concerns" about the penalties that would come with it, officials told the City Council on Monday. They want the point thresholds for getting on the list left to the department rather than written into the ordinance.

The Government Operations Committee, chaired by City Councilor Gabriela Coletta Zapata, heard two rental ordinances for about three hours on Nov. 16: Council President Liz Breadon's list (docket 1958) and Coletta Zapata's tenant protection ordinance (docket 0864). Both are listed for possible action at the council's Wednesday, Nov. 18 meeting, but officials and the chair both pointed to a working session first. "Clearly we have a little bit more work to do," Coletta Zapata said at the close (watch at 3:14:56).

What officials said

Chief of Operations Dion Irish said he began his city career as a housing inspector in 1995 (watch at 15:14). He said the 2012 rental registration ordinance already provided for a chronic offender registry, but the city never put it into practice; the pandemic shifted priorities soon after he became inspections commissioner in 2019 (watch at 16:48).

  • How big the list would be: "around 100 properties max," based on what New York and Chicago report, an official said (watch at 45:56). Whether that means 100 landlords or 100 buildings would depend on the data.
  • How the system works now: each violation report "is an isolated incident," with no running point total for a building (watch at 26:34). Owners get 14, 21 or 30 days to make repairs before a case goes to Housing Court (watch at 18:55). Officials said 141 housing violations were waiting for reinspection and 83 cases were waiting for constables to serve papers. They did not have a count of cases already in court.
  • Zoning relief: code violations and zoning are "completely separate matters," so a landlord in Housing Court can still win zoning relief today (watch at 20:33).
  • Registration: about 140,291 rental units are registered, which officials put at 74% of the city's rentals (watch at 1:26:51). This year the city sent its first failure-to-register cases all the way through the process to a lien (watch at 22:09).

The administration's reservations

Officials said they have "some concerns around the prohibitions and the penalties," such as barring listed landlords from city contracts and zoning relief. They said these could create "constitutional challenges" when the city tries to connect corporations to owners, and that public naming "is a strong enough tool" along with current enforcement (watch at 52:29). Later, asked by City Councilor Enrique Pepén whether they had major concerns, they said "overall... we're aligned" (watch at 1:18:21).

City Councilor John FitzGerald asked how the point thresholds were set. The ordinance uses higher thresholds for landlords with more units. Officials said that table came out of 2012 talks that included the real estate board, and asked that the thresholds be set by the department instead. FitzGerald said that could leave "legal wiggle room" for landlords who dispute their listing (watch at 57:46). City Councilor Sharon Durkan said her district has landlords with far more than 500 units, and suggested the table needs work (watch at 2:26:03).

Other councilors

  • Ed Flynn asked whether the city could avoid "public shaming" and instead "work with people in a respectful manner" (watch at 30:22).
  • Miniard Culpepper said District 7 had 32.7 housing complaints per 1,000 units in 2025, the second-highest rate of any district, and asked whether inspectors are assigned accordingly (watch at 1:03:09).
  • Breadon said 87% of Allston-Brighton residents rent, compared with 65% citywide (watch at 10:29).

New York City Public Advocate Jumaane Williams testified by video about his office's annual worst landlords list, which the office has published since 2010 (watch at 1:31:02). Tenant groups testified in support. Following our usual practice, we do not name residents who testified.

What's next

The committee is expected to hold a working session to revise the texts. Each ordinance then needs a committee report, a council vote and the mayor's signature. Our Nov. 10 preview lists what each would change, including Coletta Zapata's proposal to raise fines from $300 a month to up to $300 a day.

Support Boston Politics

Keep Boston Politics free for everyone

Boston Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime